← Return to Exercise to strengthen bones (for osteoporosis)

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
@callalloo

Thanks, Teri!

I've been wondering how safe the vibrating plate technology really is since one of our fellow contributors here has had a few fractures recently diagnosed and has been using a home vibrating plate at home with much enthusiasm. Note, that cause and effect aren't clear but it is thought-provoking to contemplate. And she herself wonders if using the plates caused the fractures.

Since I've not used them but had been thinking of it, I was hesitant to post anything negative about them [already having a reputation here of being, shall we say, committed to due diligence and undiluted facts wherever they lead, lol ;-)].

But even able-bodied young jock types have hurt themselves by over-doing on these 'machines,' some seriously. (One noteworthy unjury is detached retinas, yikes.) And one study noted the danger of not standing fully vertical so the force/energy can be fully dissipated during the inter-disc spinal transit. Yet some of the online exercises advocate various off-verticle postures like leaning from the waist to 'concentrate the force in lower spinal chord' (sic).

So I'm glad that you're reconsidering the plates and hope others research them and approach them with appropriate diligence to determine best use. I've been working on some of Dr. Fishman's yoga and think they're unobtrusively powerful and love them...

Jump to this post


Replies to "Thanks, Teri! I've been wondering how safe the vibrating plate technology really is since one of..."

Hi @callalloo, I think it was @bunky44 posted the comments about the fractures. I hope she's okay. I saw an earlier posting that mentioned Margaret Martin has exercises for those with fractures.
I was using the Eilison Bolt twice a day, for about ten months, two fifteen minute "bone building" programs and they were intense! I'm fortunate nothing happened. The paper I had read about Whole Body Vibration Therapy bone building didn't mention any adverse effects for the test subjects, and I assume they were using the high vibration machines, but there was no discussion of G (gravatational force), just Hz, acceleration, and amplitude of motion.

I thought I had done my due diligence, but apparently not, and Margaret Martin's article is fairly recent.

I'm glad you are enjoying Dr. Fishman's yoga. I was doing the Algaecal versions for a while, and worked my way through the three versions. They're agonizingly slow. but useful for getting the proper form. Lately, I've been enjoying the fast pace of Dr. Fishman's video.

Take care.