← Return to After breast cancer: 12 years out, questions about recurrence

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
@callalloo

Thank you, I'm blushing. I don't have a medical background but my mom was a doctor. And I'm curious about a lot of things so a researcher by nature. When I got the Bad News Biopsy last fall, it was my habit to dive into the literature. For one thing, I wanted to learn as much as possible so my doctors' consults didn't waste time on the basics but we could spend the time looking at treatment possibilities. I took quantitative analysis coursework in school so that helped put the studies' statistics in perspective.

There was a brilliant article by the New York Times writer, Natalie Angier, about medical statistics. She wrote about the scientists Stephen Jay Gould was diagnosed with a rare, vicious cancer in his 30s and, basically, could expect to die soon. He analyzed all of the studies and found a lot of holes in the studies, bad statistics, corrupted data pools, etc., and picked his own treatment path and decided the data against survival were basically junk. Then he lived another 30 or so years and died of something else.

I read that article in a book of her science essays and never forgot it. All studies of human subjects are inherently flawed because we are not perfect substitutes for each other so isolating just one variable and freezing all the other identical variables is impossible. If we can do our best to get, and remain, healthy, we're already better than the mean (average) versus most study data universes. I find that very encouraging. And liked Stephen Jay Gould. And Mark Twain's, "There's lies, damn lies and statistics?"

Jump to this post


Replies to "Thank you, I'm blushing. I don't have a medical background but my mom was a doctor...."

I totally agree.... I could not tolerate any of the AIs prescribed. They made me swell up, couldnt stand on my feet, couldnt use my hands, they swelled like baseball mitts, dizziness, and basically bedridden. I tokk myself off of them. My oncologist said all I could do was pray and at least I managed 6 months on the pills..... I did all the herbal things and improved about 40%. Then I went all in on diet and excercise. I eat plant based whole foods no oil starch diet, and I have lost 51 pounds since June. I can walk 2 miles every day right now, and while my fingers still dont bend, I have no arthritic pain. I also do chair yoga. I feel better than I ever have, and am no longer afraid of recurrence. I am in my 3rd year out. I plan to repost for the next 20 years!!! Good luck on your journey. There is nothing wrong with thrying medication free. My blood pressure which was always 170/95 while on blood pressure meds is now an even 110 to 120 over 80 to 90. I have never felt better. Good luck on your journey!!