Accelerated bone loss is absolutely a given with AIs. Aromatase inhibitors deplete estrogen by preventing its production. Estrogen helps bone cell turnover [old bone sheds, new bone forms] and helps protect the coronary system in some ways, and has numerous other functions still being identified. [Cognitive health thought to be among them, partly by maintaining endothelial tissue, ergo arteries' ability to rebound. But not yet established as fact.] Women who took hormone-replacement therapy frequently took it for these purported benefits of "estrogen protection."
So ridding the body of estrogen affects these processes. What isn't a given, is the rate of loss of protection. Someone with osteopenia might have faster bone loss than someone with advanced osteoporosis according to my endocrinologist whose practice is primarily osteoporosis and diabetes. And who was formerly with the NIH bone-renewal research section.
I declined aromatase inhibitors because of what estrogen depletion does. Time will tell if that was a mistake but my OncotypeDX showed a 5% risk of recurrence if I didn't take them or tamoxifen, which translates to a 95% chance of no recurrence within 9 years anywhere in the body. Being older helped here. As I see it, going on anastrozole also means going on an osteoporosis treatment. Soon thereafter if not immediately, depending upon age. Or if pre-menopausal, taking tamoxifen, which does not deplete the body of estrogen, though also has side effects to be aware of.
There are no longitudinal studies of women with breast cancer who decline meds. My surgeon is collecting anecdotal data among the older patients who are increasingly rejecting them. And looking to design a study as there's very little data about breast cancer among women over 65, many of whom are not even getting mammograms. So this is a kind of data-deficient area...
Thanks for your comprehensive post as always. Do you have a medical background? It’s disappointing that we can’t get straight answers in a medically sponsored forum. Some of us are spreading misinformation and we don’t know it. Some doctors appear to be spreading misinformation which is totally unacceptable. This isn’t a book club. It’s life or death so we need to be sharing facts not just our opinions and feelings.