← Return to Anyone tried Dry Needling or Acupuncture for Pain or Neuropathy?

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
@jetsetter

When I was going to PT for neck pain, they would put warm compresses on my neck/shoulder, while at the same time they would hook me up to a TENS machine for 15 minutes (small electrical pulses into tight trapezius muscles).

Then the Physical therapist would come in and insert 4-5 long very thin needles into the muscle area that was affected. I went to another PT provider and they hooked up the TENS machine to the needles. After that I would do the stretching exercises.

Acupuncture uses very thin needles inserted into acupressure points throughout the body. The goal is to break through blockages in the meridians or between the acupressure points. The needles are not put where the pain is necessarily, but at the acupressure point corresponding the affected body part. For example, one day I told her I could feel aching in my ankle after the session. She said the ankle acupressure point corresponds to the neck, and I was there to work on relieving my neck pain.

When I asked the doctor of Asian and Oriental medicine what the difference is between acupuncture and dry needling she said acupuncture puts needles into acupressure points and dry needling uses needles into the trigger points of the muscles.

Of course acupuncture is not widely accepted in main-stream medicine in the US, but my acupuncture doctor says when she worked in NJ before moving her practice to Alabama, she worked hand-in-hand with pain management doctors and chiropractors. I think it definitely has merit and I have seen improvement in my sinus, neck and general pain level.

Great question, hope this helped (or brought up more questions!).

Jump to this post


Replies to "When I was going to PT for neck pain, they would put warm compresses on my..."

This is a great explanation. My husband taught in a school that taught both Chiropractic, Massage Therapy and Oriental Medicine/Acupuncture (3 separate degrees.)

I was often treated by massage or acupuncture students under the supervision of their preceptors. I quickly learned that some really understood the human body, the theory of oriental medicine and the associated skills with needles - they were very adept by the time they graduated. Others were not so proficient, caused bleeding, bruising, spasms...

I personally did not find dry needling helpful, but acupuncture has helped me through a number of tough situations.

Similarly, I am VERY picky about who does my massages, because some practitioners are ineffective, others seem to have magic hands. Some have a "set routine", others work with you, and let your body guide the massage.

And there is only one chiropractor who has ever made me feel better with his treatments - he can pinpoint where my spine is "locked up" by walking behind me from the reception area to his treatment room. He will not do dry needling, because he says it "takes a lot of training to do it right" - he leaves it to the acupuncturist in his office.

So in alternative and complimentary medicine, just like other medical practices, one can experience a wide range of skills.

Have you experienced differences in the skills of therapists you have seen?
Sue

Thank you. Meantime the headache carries on - 28 months now.