@ray666 Detail is good. Other opinions are useful in a few ways. You may get several opinions in agreement of the need for surgery, and you would know that you are getting an honest evaluation. You may get wildly different opinions that place blame on other diseases instead of your spine, and you can tell if a surgeon is paying attention or trying to dismiss you if their opinion doesn't make a lot of sense with what you know about your symptoms. I know in saying this it might conflict with a trained medical opinion, but surgeons do pick and choose their cases. I have been in that spot of being passed over and surgeons and staff not paying attention to real spine related symptoms and not connecting them to my imaging and making excuses why they can't help me. I had learned enough about spine issues that I knew when I was not getting a good opinion. The surgeons at the top of their game did not have trouble understanding my case, but it took an opinion with a 6th surgeon until I found a great surgeon and went forward with surgery.

You may get different solutions with different manufacturers of spinal hardware because different surgeons have different preferences. They have to be trained in the use of the products by the manufacturers. Some offer artificial disc replacement but only if you have good bone quality and do not have instability. Some have PEEK cages which is a type on inert plastic. Some are titanium. Some cages screw in with angled screws and do not require a plate to be placed on the front of the spine. Some surgeons prefer to use a bone graft because it heals better (according to mine) and for me the best choice of all was no hardware, just the bone graft and I was careful until it fused. Some place rods and do a "curve correction" but that also removes the ability to move. There is going to be a compromise, but there is a choice with the understanding that not every patient is a good candidate for every solution. In the end, you have to educate yourself as best you can, and make an educated choice as to which surgeon you wish to hire for the job.

Think of it that way. They must earn the job not by pressuring a patient, but by explaining the benefit of the solution they propose vs the risks. Getting other opinions is normal and expected, and if a surgeon objects to it, you could look elsewhere. If a surgeon does good work, they should not worry about peer reviews. They are reviewed by insurance companies and Medicare anyway as well as online patient reviews. In order to get insurance clearance for surgery, they must submit their plan for review and approval in order to get paid by health insurance companies. Some surgeons are in private practice in their own facilities for profit. I talked to a high pressure surgeon in a group of 11 doctors who owned a surgical center, and he ran out of the room to avoid answering my questions. Then he mistook my leg pain as being caused by something else and told me to go to rehab and fix that first, then come back for spine surgery. I got e mail solicitations posing as surveys about my health for 2 years that were sniffing for business. Of course I couldn't fix my leg pain because it was caused by the spine problem in my neck and the 6th surgeon who was at Mayo recognized this.

Opinions matter. I knew enough to know which doctor gave me the best option and I had been reading about spine surgery for a few years. I also looked for any disciplinary action, and on the positive side, I read the surgeon's research papers to see if their interests were a good match for my case. If you found a surgeon who is a good match and is respected by their peers and want to proceed with that doctor, it is your choice. If you need more opinions to be able make an informed choice, get them. You have one chance to make a good choice. Not all surgeons are trying to sell you on surgery, and I was very suspicious of one who did that toward me. The surgeon at Mayo made an offer to help me and he didn't need to convince me of anything. I knew he was giving an honest evaluation of my condition and he would not have financial gain because of doing surgery because Mayo surgeons are employees and are not paid extra for doing surgeries.

@ray666

I was just told my X-rays show severe cervical Foraminal stenosis that has worsened since 2019.

I’d love to know the outcome of your situation. I’m reading old posts from 2021.