Has anyone had a tight band feeling after total knee replacement?

Posted by mhort1213 @mhort1213, Feb 28, 2019

I am 8 weeks post TKR and have had this very tight band around my knee since week one. My Dr at 6 wks says it is normal and will go away. Has anyone else had this and did it go away and when?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Joint Replacements Support Group.

@rickraleigh

Well, I think if surgeons told folks everything about side effects, complications, etc., a lot fewer of them would get TKRs.

Jump to this post

Every time I think about joint replacement, I think back to my youth, before such a thing was possible, and how many of my older friends and neighbors suffered near total disability from worn out knees and hips. I remember the poor "babas" hobbling to the side entrance of the church, leaning on walking sticks. I remember the older men in the neighborhood, trying to shovel and mow, until caring people like my parents realized and mobilized us kids to help. I remember everyone being amazed that at age 60 my Dad and our pastor could still play softball with us "at that age". Because accessibility was not a "thing" in my old neighborhood, as their disability progressed, they were virtual prisoners in their homes or on their porches, unable to manage the stairs, and nowhere to go if they could - no curb cuts, no street level access to anything, no ability to go to church...

At age 50, I could not mount a ladies' bike, or walk up and down stairs due to arthritis in my hips - if the above were my future, I would have died of depression. Instead, I have had 5 hip implants, numerous smaller ortho repairs to hands knees and feet. And don't forget PT and pain therapy...

Now I think about 2021 - probably most of my 70 something friends have one or more replaced joints or repaired.We bike, walk, chase grandkids, paddleboard, play tennis and pickleball, ski...all things that were long last to prior generations.

Yes, we have complications and pain, but compared to 2-3 generations ago, we are living miracles. Just a different point of view. When the times come to replace these arthritic knees, I will not hesitate - just find the best surgeon & PT available.
Sue

REPLY
@sueinmn

Every time I think about joint replacement, I think back to my youth, before such a thing was possible, and how many of my older friends and neighbors suffered near total disability from worn out knees and hips. I remember the poor "babas" hobbling to the side entrance of the church, leaning on walking sticks. I remember the older men in the neighborhood, trying to shovel and mow, until caring people like my parents realized and mobilized us kids to help. I remember everyone being amazed that at age 60 my Dad and our pastor could still play softball with us "at that age". Because accessibility was not a "thing" in my old neighborhood, as their disability progressed, they were virtual prisoners in their homes or on their porches, unable to manage the stairs, and nowhere to go if they could - no curb cuts, no street level access to anything, no ability to go to church...

At age 50, I could not mount a ladies' bike, or walk up and down stairs due to arthritis in my hips - if the above were my future, I would have died of depression. Instead, I have had 5 hip implants, numerous smaller ortho repairs to hands knees and feet. And don't forget PT and pain therapy...

Now I think about 2021 - probably most of my 70 something friends have one or more replaced joints or repaired.We bike, walk, chase grandkids, paddleboard, play tennis and pickleball, ski...all things that were long last to prior generations.

Yes, we have complications and pain, but compared to 2-3 generations ago, we are living miracles. Just a different point of view. When the times come to replace these arthritic knees, I will not hesitate - just find the best surgeon & PT available.
Sue

Jump to this post

You are correct! My 2 aunts were on walkers and wheel chairs in the 1960s. They were in their 50’s. They were born with hip dysplasia, and so was I. No hip replacements for them at that time.

I love my new hips. I got my first one at age 50. It was a miracle. My bad hips and a waddling gait hastened the demise of my knee. Total hips were easy, the knee was hard. But it had to be done as it was too unstable for me to have a normal life.

That tight feeling is aggravating but being able to walk, hike, work in my gardens, is worth everything I’ve been through. Still have lots I want to do! I’ve made peace with it. Thank you Sue for reminding us of the miracle of modern medicine.

REPLY
@scgraham

True. It seems many people on this site have this side effect from TKR. It would be helpful if before TKR a patient could be informed of common after effects. The part that was frustrating to me the first year of my recovery was the complete lack of information on this phenomenon.

Jump to this post

Truth!

REPLY

I'm almost 11 months into a TKR and I have the tight band feeling. My sense is that it is normal.

REPLY

My doctor said he will redo my knees and change the spacers.

REPLY
@futureglory

My doctor said he will redo my knees and change the spacers.

Jump to this post

That’s a lot to go through.I’d explore every alternative before I would go through that

REPLY

Yes. I would do more today.

REPLY

July 26 had TKR on the left. So glad I found this group. I’ve been made to feel my continuing need for narcotic pain relief is unusual. As a result of only taking a Tramadol 50 when pain is a 9 I haven’t slept in two nights and couldn’t meet with my PT. I’m to get staples out in 2 days and hope the support from this thread will help me feel confident to request a Rx refill. All the best to my fellow travelers.

REPLY
@debbie64131

I feel for you! I am almost 16 weeks & had a total manipulation 2 weeks ago. The tight band feeling left for only 2 days after my manipulation . I still go to PT & have pain all the time. Water therapy feels great but I can’t live in the pool. My doctor said the scar tissue may or may not go away. I just wish I would have known some things before I had this done!

Jump to this post

Hi so after the manipulation you never got rid of the tight band feeling? It's been awhile since your surgery, how are you doing now? I'm 4 weeks post op, and scared, I have that tight band feed and pain.. iam at 114 flexion, so it is bending. But still painful.. thank you, I hope your still on here and can give me your experience!

REPLY
@scgraham

As many of us are suffering with this crazy after effect of tkr, you would think these doctors could figure out what causes this and what can be done. This is the most frustrating part for me at 18 Months post surgery. I was told i may have to live with this.

Jump to this post

Hi but is the pain gone? I could live with it, if I wasn't having pain. I'm 4 weeks post op, terrible band feeling. I'm afraid they will want to do the manipulation though, even though my bend right now is 114%

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.