Hello @ggb21

I'd like to add my welcome to you as a new member of Mayo Clinic Connect. I had Shingles (first time) in September 2020, they were on the right side of my back in the waistband area. I remember staying in a nightgown most of the month to avoid pressure on that area.

I've also had several surgeries of the upper digestive tract which have left scars (and probably scar tissue) in or near the breast bone so I too have problems finding and wearing a comfortable bra. I always get a bra bigger than what I really need to keep the pressure off of the scarred area. This might be helpful to you if you want to try it.

The suggestion of @amandajro is also a good one. The sheepskins padding might be helpful.

As it appears that it has been just 16 days since your Shingles outbreak, it could be that you are expecting relief too soon. I had a full month of discomfort and it does come back periodically, but not as bad as it was originally.

A dermatologist might be very helpful in finding some answers. Have you seen a dermatologist?