Osteoporosis treatment or strontium citrate?

Posted by bonelady @bonelady, May 10, 2018

Is reclast a safe treatment for osteoporosis I have not done anything so far except strontium citrate?

***Director's Note:***
There’s not enough research to know if strontium fights osteoporosis. Also, the FDA doesn’t regulate supplements in the same way as prescription drugs, so it's not possible to know if if they are safe or work well or even how much of the main ingredient they contain.

If you want to take a strontium supplement, it is recommended to ask your doctor first.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

@kathleen1314

Interesting side note to the posting on Activator X

The activator-x discussed here seems to be Vit K2. Found in certain animal and fermented foods, K2 has been tied to many benefits including bone health and cancer prevention. There is another link found in research to the popular Budwig diet which is found on the internet as a cancer prevention diet; this diet contains fermented products, as well as, eliminating sugars and the famous Budwig chemical concoction of flaxseed oil and cottage cheese which uses the chemical reaction between flaxseed oil and cottage cheese to flood the body with oxygen in the hope of preventing cancers.

I just found the link between Activator-X and the Budwig Diet interesting (fermentedfoods) ..not suggesting either, although I do use the Budwig diet flaxseed oil and cottage cheese concoction. I am less likely to use the fermented foods or completely eliminate sugars...probably to my detriment, sadly.
https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/vitamin-k2#sources
https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/320352#making-the-mixture
https://www.budwig-stiftung.de/en/dr-johanna-budwig/her-research.html

Jump to this post

I thought vitimin K clots the blood. A friend of mine was on blood thinning meds and hit his head...wouldn't stop bleeding. ER gave him a shot of Vitimin K. Since I need some sort of thinner (using Horse Chestnut for vein health but do take a baby aspirin sometimes) I'm not sure about using vitimin K. Any thoughts please? Thank you all so much!

REPLY
@lynneat

I don't have a natural homeopathic doctor in this state. I'd like to know specifics about how much any doctor (natural) advises. I've seen friends lose their lives taking meds that cause more trouble, then taking meds for that, then they die and I wonder if it weren't the prescriptions that caused it. I was told I needed meds for high BP. I broke out in a rash. I researched and found hawthorn (but it restricts the heart) and Hibiscus (relaxes blood vessels) so I took Hibiscus and after a month my BP is perfect! I want the same results for my brittle bones 🙂 Can anyone please say what dosages and what vitimins etc they are taking? This is NOT prescribing. Just sharing. It's up to us to evaluate and research for ourselves but first you need to know what is working for others. A starting point. Please. Thanks so much! 🙂

Jump to this post

@lynneat Look at healthline.com and naturel medicine journal.com those are 2good sites I have osteoporosis and Dr told me to take calcium citrate 600 mg 2x a day along with Vit D 5000 mg as well I do some herbs that are recommended in healthline Good luck Besides the vitamins exercises are needed .

REPLY
@lynneat

I thought vitimin K clots the blood. A friend of mine was on blood thinning meds and hit his head...wouldn't stop bleeding. ER gave him a shot of Vitimin K. Since I need some sort of thinner (using Horse Chestnut for vein health but do take a baby aspirin sometimes) I'm not sure about using vitimin K. Any thoughts please? Thank you all so much!

Jump to this post

It seems what I read re vitamin K2 is that it’s a + for the bones. I mentioned it to my Dr and she was horrified that I was taking it. Said would never recommend to her patients because of the blood clot effects. I’m terrified of bone fractures but at the same time dread going back to Fosmax Doing everything I can to avoid.

REPLY
@npolanco

It seems what I read re vitamin K2 is that it’s a + for the bones. I mentioned it to my Dr and she was horrified that I was taking it. Said would never recommend to her patients because of the blood clot effects. I’m terrified of bone fractures but at the same time dread going back to Fosmax Doing everything I can to avoid.

Jump to this post

I take vitamin K2 and D3 along with other supplements for my neuropathy. You might want to press your doctor for specific information on why she is against K2. This is an older article from 2012 and a newer one from this past January.

The Emerging Role of Vitamin K2: https://www.uspharmacist.com/article/the-emerging-role-of-vitamin-k2
The Medical Benefits of Vitamin K2 on Calcium-Related Disorders: https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/2/691

REPLY
@johnbishop

I take vitamin K2 and D3 along with other supplements for my neuropathy. You might want to press your doctor for specific information on why she is against K2. This is an older article from 2012 and a newer one from this past January.

The Emerging Role of Vitamin K2: https://www.uspharmacist.com/article/the-emerging-role-of-vitamin-k2
The Medical Benefits of Vitamin K2 on Calcium-Related Disorders: https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/2/691

Jump to this post

Thank you for posting the links to the two very informative articles. Like someone mentioned in another post “we have to be our own advocate “ adding these articles to discuss with Dr.

REPLY
@bonelady

I have osteoporosis and am afraid of the treatments for it have been trying strontium citrate not sure about my decision.

Jump to this post

In the L.A. times Scientist talked about osteoporosis They found that by adding this magic bullet Silicon along with strontium citrate, VitD,Vit K,Boron ,Calcium it all works on the bones and osteoporosis This article was sent to me by the women's health articles it is also in the New England Medical medical journal So Ladies let's add the strontium the Boron K and everything else that they're talkin about the Silicon they really said was a Magic Bullet they called it

REPLY
@clarkedu

I am actively and urgently in the process of deciding which osteoporosis treatment I want to "pitch" to my doctors. Fosomax is the formulary for my HMO, but that does not appeal to me at all. I feel that I need something that is shown to rebuild bone (15 lumbar and thoracic vertebral compression fractures). Initially Forteo was top contender (refrigeration requirement is an issue) until I came across Tymlos (refrigeration being easier to manage is one of several benefits over Forteo). Can and should treatments such as these be used in conjunction with strontium citrate, about which I know nothing by the way? Any feedback to help me through this maze will be highly appreciated

Jump to this post

Some of these postings are several years old. Osteoporosis treatments have come a long way since 2018. My rheumatologist and endocrinologist both recommended Evenity. In 12 months I saw significant improvement in my spine but not in my femur. My belief is that my lack of exercise caused the decrease in bone density in my femur so now I am serious about exercise. I've transitioned to Prolia after 12 months of Evenity. Still no side effects as far as I can tell. The monthly injections of Evenity were in the doctor's office and were not bad at all. With Prolia I will have a shot twice a year and I've had the first one and it was not bad either. Personally, I prefer taking a drug that has been vetted instead of cobbling together several chemicals that are not proven scientifically to work and be safe for the majority of people who may be taking several drugs that might interact with them. Whatever you decide to take please do it with the guidance and supervision of a qualified medical doctor.

REPLY

My husband has been advised to have a Reclast infusion. I am opposed to his having it because I had one a month ago and am still struggling with high blood pressure and new aches and pains. (I’ve never had above 120/60 in my 75 years and I have practiced yoga for 10 years).
Will you please advise me as to what, besides calcium and vitamin D, we can add to his supplements so he can avoid my tribulations.
Do you recommend Boron? Strontium? What strength?
I was crushed to realize that Reclast will be recirculating in my body for three years.i hate this blood pressure and ensuing crankiness.

REPLY
@suerc

Does anyone take Forteo ? My Dr wants me to start taking this. My fear is the cost. Injecting myself daily. and I don't hear much about it.

Jump to this post

I had taken Forteo for one year and bone density declined, I was 55 years old at the time. Started taking AlgaeCal Plus for over two years, slight improvement in hips 2.4 now and spine declined to 3.8.
59 years old with a horrible bone density, just got a Prolia injection and I ache every day. I discontinued AlgaeCal Plus and just started taking OsteoMD which seems to be rated number one. I don’t know how well it’ll work but willing to try. All the very best to all of us suffering with osteoporosis. 🙏

REPLY
@lucy59

I had taken Forteo for one year and bone density declined, I was 55 years old at the time. Started taking AlgaeCal Plus for over two years, slight improvement in hips 2.4 now and spine declined to 3.8.
59 years old with a horrible bone density, just got a Prolia injection and I ache every day. I discontinued AlgaeCal Plus and just started taking OsteoMD which seems to be rated number one. I don’t know how well it’ll work but willing to try. All the very best to all of us suffering with osteoporosis. 🙏

Jump to this post

Hello @lucy59 and welcome to Mayo Clinic Connect. Thank you so much for joining the discussion to share your experience with medications. It would be great for you to provide some periodic updates on your progress with OsetoMD and the Prolia injection so members like @suerc can learn from you.

How long until you will get an update on your bone density?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.