← Return to Personal Air Purifiers and Safety/Effectiveness

Discussion
phoenixrises (@phoenixrises)

Personal Air Purifiers and Safety/Effectiveness

MAC & Bronchiectasis | Last Active: Oct 17, 2020 | Replies (17)

Comment receiving replies
@phoenixrises

Thank you, John and Sue, for your thoughts and suggestions. I've read many articles on air purifiers including those that use negative ionizers – including the articles you suggested. I have 2 air purifier units (HEPA/charcoal-based) in 2 rooms (living room and bedroom) in my home – and I wouldn't use a floor unit that emits ozone (either from negative ionizers and/or UV light). I also try to get fresh air with open windows or taking a walk when possible.

But the personal air purifier that I was considering purchasing (that I would wear when out, at stores, or in the company of other people, or rooms in my house that don't have an air purifier), only seems available as a 'negative ionizer' (or with UV, which I definitely wouldn't get because of ozone emission) – apparently, no vendor has made a personal air purifier that uses HEPA/charcoal maybe because it's not possible due to the small size of it (?).

I was wondering if I could try it and see if I develop negative symptoms (e.g., cough, chest pain, or shortness of breath) – but then I worry that I may not show symptoms but damage could be done to my lungs that I'm unaware?

The reason I want to consider it is because I barely go out (since last January '20 when I got sick!) and have to decline any invitations anywhere (especially with winter approaching….everything is indoors and people don't wear masks in their home gatherings). I also live with someone who works out into the field every day due to his job and so I risk exposure there when he comes home. If the personal air purifier really does work (as many people have remarked positively in reviews), I thought it might protect me – but I was leery of hurting my lungs further. This is so frustrating and upsetting!

Jump to this post


Replies to "Thank you, John and Sue, for your thoughts and suggestions. I've read many articles on air..."

@phoenixrises I bought a negative ion generator many years ago because I thought it would help my chronic sinus infections. It was a disaster. I had it next to my bed at night and the first night it gave me heart palpitations. I called the company for a refund and the woman told me that the same thing happened to her brother. Of course, that little detail wasn't in the advertisement. I also tried a room-sized ionizer and immediately got a runny nose from the ozone. I think Sue has the right approach. (BTW, a negative ion generator is another name for ionizer.)