GrandmaR went to Dr today. Gailb saw a nurse practitioner Theresa I told him I wanted to avoid surgery if possible as we talked he agreed with what Im doing is good except he is sending me to Aqua Therapy 2times a week plus I do chair exercises 2times a week also Thanks guys for your concern I still have pain but he didn't think it was bad enough for surgery I would have had it if he felt it would be helpful. Oh well such is life