← Return to Do petite women get over-diagnosed with osteoporosis?

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
Profile picture for gently @gently

laren3, W
the discrepancy in inherent in the 2-dimensional dexa measurement. With a dexa score, the actual bmd would be higher in a small bone than it would be in a large bone because dexa doesn't register volume of the bone.
The numbers generated through dexa and QCT can't be directly compared.
Because I have an older spine, the concern was that dexa might be giving me a better T score by including bone spurs. With a lower score, I might have chosen a different medication (Tymlos instead of Forteo).
QCT measures trabecular bone the more delicate inner portion of the vertebrae and femoral neck. Dexa measures both cortical and trabecular bone

Jump to this post


Replies to "laren3, W the discrepancy in inherent in the 2-dimensional dexa measurement. With a dexa score, the..."

@gently Are you saying the DEXA score would show worse osteoporosis for smaller bones vs larger bones? Wouldn't a worse DEXA score indicate less BMD in the smaller bones?

@gently One thing that dexa does that REMS does not is gets skewed by arthritis which makes the scores worse.