← Return to Does reducing exposure to Mycobacteria ( NTM) work?

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
Profile picture for jnmy @jnmy

@cholash What an interesting post and responses to it.
There is a fairly wide range of opinions even in the scientific community about how to avoid or who might be susceptible to NTMs and MAC.

Is there research that shows that ‘never smokers’ are less likely to have MAC? That might make some sense, but there needs to be scientific studies. Never smokers may have also been exposed to second hand smoke.

Exposure to soil and the peat moss in potting soil is something I try to avoid by masking or moistening the soil and working in non windy environments. I don’t swim in indoor pools. I use bottled spring water or a Lifestraw bottle when travelling.

It would be hugely beneficial if we could easily test water for NTM. With all the new technologies available, this might happen?

The pulmonologist’s statement that some people might be inherently more susceptible to these diseases should be explored if there isn’t ongoing research now.

Is there a biological cause or even a precipitous event in someone’s life that coupled with other factors causes them to develop MAC?

Thanks for posting.

Jump to this post


Replies to "@cholash What an interesting post and responses to it. There is a fairly wide range of..."

@jnmy And I wonder if getting NTM or not (with BE) has to do with adherence to airway clearance. Many posts I read here, but not all, are from those who were recently diagnosed with BE and MAC at the same time so they did not know about airway clearance. Those diagnosed with BE only are instructed to do airway clearance twice day, and as a result ward off MAC/NTM.

@jnmy it’s my understanding that NTM is in most water . It’s just not a problem for the average person . “Is there a biological cause ? “ At this point, I don’t know if it’s been studied . According to my NTM specialist , she’s had a lot of BE patients that never get MAC, and they don’t practice risk prevention . I think “ predisposition “, and what exactly that is, may be the million dollar question .