Any long-term success stories from those NOT taking hormone therapy?

Posted by lj22 @lj22, Mar 30, 2025

Hello all, I'm fairly new to this forum. Have previously described my case, early 60's, Stage 1, HR +, Her2-, lumpectomy and now radiation. Soon, I'll need to make a decision about whether to take hormone therapy. I've ruled out Tamoxifen, and if AI (Anastrozole), I would need Zometa due to osteopenia. I am otherwise healthy and take no other daily meds. I am also looking into natural AI's in foods and supplements. (Have reviewed Predict model, showing relatively high survival rates, but unclear on recurrence rates from his model.)

Anyone in a similar situation who has decided not to take AIs, and is doing well long term? Would like to hear your experiences. Many thanks. LJ

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Breast Cancer Support Group.

Profile picture for peggydobbs @peggydobbs

To vegada: see my answer above. PeggyDobbs

Jump to this post

I had my cancer in 2020 so that is likely the answer as to why I wasn't offered it. I was originally offered chemo but I insisted on getting the Mammaprint test as well in addition to Oncotype and my mammaprint was low risk. Given my stage, size, grade and mammaprint results, 8 doctors then said no chemo and reversed their recommendation. My Oncotype was a 29. Then I also did the RSCLIN model a year or so later and it showed very low risk as well. So I will never know if I made the right decision about not having chemo but I can say the Oncotype was the outlier which is why I paid for the Mammaprint test to see if that genomic test was more in line with my clinical tumor characteristics.

REPLY
Profile picture for sealskin @sealskin

Hi! Same! Ah the gold standard treatment doled out to all of us with a big dose of fear. I had no support. I did radiation which has been destructive to a tear duct that had to be reconstructed. I had chose not to take Anastrozole but was encouraged by an online survivor so I started Anastrozole 6 months from lumpectomy Sept. 2022. I took it for 1.5 years and quit because of many side effects that destroyed all quality of life-it was poison! And I noticed last March 2024 1/2 my beautiful hair was gone. And today, a year later my hair has thinned at a fast rate the last 4 months and I will be bald in 4 months if it doesn’t stop thinning. My hair has just stopped growing- what’s left is still silky and beautiful. Quality of life and my cognitive abilities and sleep returned after about 4 months of stopping the AI. The bone and muscle pain, inability to sleep were extreme. I was letting fear rule and finally chose quality of life. If cancer returns I’ll deal with it then. I have enough on my plate as it is. Good luck!

Jump to this post

I agree with you.
Castor oil makes eyebrow grow, why not hair. In glass or safe plastic. Google Barbara O'Neil and Castor oil. Amazing this Castor oil is.
Best to you

REPLY

Three years since lumpectomy and 5 accelerated radiation sessions. Not taking any anti estrogen drugs, doctor supports this due to decades of horrible menopause issues which would return/worsen on Rx. Grade 1 tumor, tiny, no duct or lymph involvement. Eat whole food plant based diet, no oil, salt or sugar. No alcohol or smoking. Follow dr. Michael greger on nutrition facts.org for soy and flaxseed protocols.

REPLY

Stage 1 Class 3 in 1998.
I don’t use hormones, but my cancer was double negative.

REPLY

Same as you re: cancer diagnosis-2022 20 radiations that destroyed a tear duct that was reconstructed a year later. Began Anastrozole 5 months after lumpectomy April 5, 22 and took for 1.5 years. My friend was also taking anastrozole and we both suffered memory dysfunction, impossible to sleep, relentless hot flashes, severe muscle and joint pain, heart damage, high blood pressure from suffering effects and no sleep. High cholesterol, and loss of 1/3 of my hair which has accelerated during the last year having stopped the toxic anastrozole.
I had no life or brain. All symptoms cleared after 5 months stopping except hair stopped growing and soon to be bald. I am crushed.
Good luck. I don’t trust their gold standard and doctors agreeing to push AIs on women with breast cancer for five years. And then they will play on your fear and try to coerce you to pay for the drug for another ten years!
I had a small lump and no lymph involved but Dr took it anyway. She threatened me when I stopped taking Anastrozole, Dr Christine Lee said, “you’d best take it your body is full of cancer.” Dr Lee declared, “I’m not your doctor anymore.” I have PTSD from Dr Lee’s abuse.
Good luck.
Jan

REPLY
Profile picture for brightside21 @brightside21

Ive stopped too.
I'm having every test done to check more frequently for any reccurrance.
The predict tool is not very helpful & makes a decision difficult to make when there's NO info on recurrances. All we are told is it will be much higher that the predict death rates.
It felt like a step in to the darkness as all I wanted to know was WHAT IS MY % RISK OF RECURRANCE? no one could answer me.
I've made my decision on my quality of life which is definately better OFF Als/ Amotase inhibitors.
I can only eat & sleep well & keep active & avoid alcohol (special occasions may be ) to support my decision & pray 🙏
I did get the support from 2 oncologists as I asked for a 2nd opinion before deciding & both agreed the ALs were limiting my life quality & I would improve both mentally & physically off them.
So I stopped & I am happier, healthier & more active so it's been a good decision.
Good luck making yours.

Jump to this post

Hi Brightside,
Are you able to share more of your BC Stage/Age of occurrence and if you had radiation/lumpectomy? I've had a successful lumpectomy, clear margins, negative lymph nodes, 5 day partial breast targeted radiation therapy, I'm in perimenopause, and Tamoxifin as all the AI options seem like the side effects are really bad and may cause other major health issues. I don't think the USA offers a lower dose of Tamoxifen....
Thank you for all the above shares.

REPLY
Profile picture for guillermina @guillermina

I also have decided not to take aromatase inhibitors. I have fibromyalgia, osteopenia, and atrial fibrillation (afib). I’ve had a stroke that was attributed to afib. At 86 I was diagnosed with stage 2 invasive lobular cancer. This cancer grows flat and is a little harder to detect. I had a screening mammogram and was called back for a diagnostic mammogram. I had a lumpectomy of my right breast (the surgeon couldn’t clean edges) followed by 21 radiation sessions. I read about a FES PET-CT scan FES PET-CT for Breast Cancer Services - NYC & Westchester | ColumbiaDoctors - New York | ColumbiaDoctors. I asked my oncologist to order this procedure. I live in Virginia and had to travel to Duke University in North Carolina to get one. The results were good. No cancer in other parts of my body. My oncologist said that I can have this screening annually.

Jump to this post

@guillermina I was diagnosed with Stage 2 ILC ER+, PR+ Her2- at 66 years old. Had mastectomy, 16 session chemo, second surgery to get clear margins and 25 radiation sessions. Tried Letrozole and Exemestane with terrible side effects. Been on Anastrazole every other day and Verzenio daily for a month.
Side Effects and osteoporosis.
I want to go off all drugs.
I live in Virginia too and thinking this test FES PER-CT Scan could help me.
Have you found the test anywhere closer?
Thank you so much.

REPLY
Profile picture for bluesun12 @bluesun12

Hi Brightside,
Are you able to share more of your BC Stage/Age of occurrence and if you had radiation/lumpectomy? I've had a successful lumpectomy, clear margins, negative lymph nodes, 5 day partial breast targeted radiation therapy, I'm in perimenopause, and Tamoxifin as all the AI options seem like the side effects are really bad and may cause other major health issues. I don't think the USA offers a lower dose of Tamoxifen....
Thank you for all the above shares.

Jump to this post

@bluesun12 yes, 10 mg (daily) Tamoxifen was prescribed to me by my oncologist. Some women take 10 mg every other day, since it doesn't come in 5 mg (in US) & is difficult to cut in half. Trials look promising for approval of 10 mg as standard treatment in near future.

REPLY

From this early article on Tamoxifen.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41416-023-02158-5
"Reductions in recurrence after about 10 years of follow-up were 21%, 29% and 47% for 1, 2 and 5 years of treatment, respectively. The corresponding mortality reductions were 12%, 17% and 26%, respectively, with a significantly significant test for trends in both recurrence and mortality."

The quote refers to early breast cancer. You might be one of the lucky ones who don't get a recurrence, even though you don't take tamoxifen. But I, personally, would not call it a success story--which implies that you could control the outcome--just a lucky roll of the dice.

REPLY
Profile picture for peggydobbs @peggydobbs

From this early article on Tamoxifen.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41416-023-02158-5
"Reductions in recurrence after about 10 years of follow-up were 21%, 29% and 47% for 1, 2 and 5 years of treatment, respectively. The corresponding mortality reductions were 12%, 17% and 26%, respectively, with a significantly significant test for trends in both recurrence and mortality."

The quote refers to early breast cancer. You might be one of the lucky ones who don't get a recurrence, even though you don't take tamoxifen. But I, personally, would not call it a success story--which implies that you could control the outcome--just a lucky roll of the dice.

Jump to this post

@peggydobbs I started 10 mg Tamoxifen on Jan. 1st, so less than a month ago. First couple of weeks, I felt a mild headache at times. But now I feel fine & have pretty much forgotten that I even take it! It's too bad that many women refuse to even try any hormone blockers. I agree with you, they save lives.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.