Strontium citrate (Algaecal) and fractures
I am looking to see if there are any studies done that show a reduced chance of fracture from using Strontium citrate (Algaecal) as opposed to calcium. Everything I have read only mentions increase of density using it. Does anyone have doctor input or a study showing an decrease in bone fractures?
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.
Connect

@daisy17
Well, Daisy, we just had a long discussion about how that is old and now moot information. The quick synopsis is that yes, dexa over reads strontium ( the strontium dexa skew) because strontium is denser than calcium; the over read is about 10% and really doesn't matter because in terms of bone density "up is up" no matter the amount.
More importantly, REMS and TBS are not affected by strontium denser weight and both of those tests and reports show better bone density, better bone quality for strontium users. Plus research shows strontium prevents fractures around 49% other research shows strontium users have few if any side effects.
So as we strontium users say "God bless the dexa strontium skew".
@tonilynn
No, strontium is incorporated into the bone so the dexa is not set for the denser strontium and reads it higher.
But it really doesn't matter, especially after the first dexa on strontium, because "up is up" no matter the amount, no fractures are no fractures and no side effects are no side effects.
Doctors and dexa techs just don't like knowing that the dexa is not reading strontium bones exactly.
@tonilynn REMS testing is not readily available, The nearest place I can get it is about a 3 hour drive.
I had a bad reaction to Strontium Citrate (Algae Cal) I started to develop a rash after just a few doses. I immediately stopped taking when I came across a case of a woman that became covered in hives after 6 weeks of strontium citrate. I was lucky to find the woman's case and stop the strontium immediately. Rashes have subsided for the most part. Happy I did not continue and end up like the poor woman. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7985217/
@blueberre
The case which you cite is a case of DRESS, eosinophilia and systemic symptoms syndrome with an added granulomatous dermatitis. This is not a typical rash.
This is a reaction which can be found in reaction to drugs, supplements, even some foods, The woman in the population study of one was taking a wide variety of drugs and supplements. The report could not distinguish what might have caused her reaction. Her outpatient medications included levothyroxine, sumatriptan, topiramate, trazodone, and alprazolam. She also reported taking one supplement called “elderberry.” She eventually recalled taking 3 other supplements: Sleepwell, AlgaeCal Plus, and strontium citrate.
It seems that she was taking a double dose of the strontium citrate, 2times 680mg.; using algaeCal and strontium citrate, both which have strontium citrate in them.
I can find no records in research of links to the correct dose of strontium citrate; this one case is the only one which had any strontium citrate in its research .
To repeat DRESS syndrome can be tied to many supplements, drugs and even food.
Taking double the dose of any drug, supplement or every food or water can have terrible consequences.
We don't know what caused her reaction; we do know that she used a wide variety of drugs and supplements and seems to have at least use strontium very unwisely.
To quote Narnia: "Aslan is not a tame lion" , neither is strontium citrate or any drug or supplement a toy.
@kathleen1314 I agree that her reaction and mine may not be the same. I do know that I hesitated to take the strontium . I finally started due to good reviews and within 2 days, I had hives. Coincidence? Maybe, but I had taken nothing different than my regular vitamins. I have never had hives before, so I still feel that strontium caused my reaction . It is starting to subside after 3 days without taking the strontium again. Algae Cal was quick to refund me when I contactd them. Just cautioning others.
@blueberre
Ah, so you took algae Cal, not just strontium citrate.
That could be a clue.
When you evaluate a reaction you have to look at additives and everything in the product. Algae Cal has several ingredients, additives plus there are different forms of algae cal. Which one did you take?
I suggest if you are still interested in strontium citrate that you take a purer form. AOR makes a form with few additives plus it is monitored by the Canadian government where they monitor supplements the way the FDA monitors drugs.
The story is always more layered when you dig into it isn't it., and definitely not as straight forward.
I believe that I was mistaken in that AlgaeCal contains a full dose of strontium; it seems to just be a trace. Sorry for the mistake.