← Return to Value of bone turnover markers

Discussion
sebutler avatar

Value of bone turnover markers

Osteoporosis & Bone Health | Last Active: Dec 30, 2025 | Replies (21)

Comment receiving replies
Profile picture for gently @gently

kshea2, hi.
These are my thoughts regarding bone markers, but I'm not a medical person or statistician. And my doctor says that you can't use bone markers in relationship to each other.
We want our bones to break down but want a commensurate building up, CTX and P1NP are measured products of bone destruction and construction. Your 370÷82 = a ratio or 4.5, withing the range I consider preferable. At a ratio of 5 to 1, I think there is a balance where you are not building new bone, nor losing more bone than you are replacing. At 6 CTX to 1 P1NP it looks from a careful study of various clinical trials.
As brilliant as he is, the endocrinologist I see only looks at my P1NP. Since it is now double my base line, and I'm on an anabolic, he is content that the medication is still working. If I were on an antiresorptive, he would only look at the CTX for reassurance wanting it to be at least 20% lower than baseline.
He wouldn't consider your numbers to yield information without baseline.
I also consider that I need higher numbers than a younger person, because my older bones need more repair. A person with a fracture would also need higher CTX initially and higher P1NP at some point in the process

( as an unnecessary aside McCormick and Lucas both convert pg/mL to ug.L (or ng/mL before finding the ratio. Lucas remains uncertain of best ratio though he is certain that there is one.)
All of this is unnecessary to explain that to get the ratio divide the CTX by P1NP. My last bone markers were CTX334/P1NP 117 which puts me at a nice 2.8, though I'd like both numbers to be higher. My endocrinologist looked at the P1NP which is about double baseline and was happy no matter the CTX.

Jump to this post


Replies to "kshea2, hi. These are my thoughts regarding bone markers, but I'm not a medical person or..."

@gently thank you for your lucid explanation for the use of biomarkers and what they might mean. I gather that you and your doctor are using bone markers to monitor efficacy of treatment.

Do you see a role for monitoring biomarkers during a drug holiday and in between DEXAs to determine: a) whether non-drug treatment (targeted nutrition and exercise) are working? And/or b) to help consider whether drug treatment should again be resumed (started.)

If there is such a role, what frequency of testing would likely be most beneficial?