← Return to Support For Those Quitting Prolia

Discussion
formisc avatar

Support For Those Quitting Prolia

Osteoporosis & Bone Health | Last Active: Oct 2 1:39pm | Replies (306)

Comment receiving replies
Profile picture for rjd @rjd

@awesomemomx2
We are all try but due diligence is often not enough in this arena. It seems to me that, given all the variables, medical judgment is required and that means focused education and experience. Most PCPs and many specialists simply are not that committed to this medical condition. And alas, I did to go to medical school.

It is why I like Dr. M. He has been at this a long time and he learned it because he was personally impacted...greatly. His books are impressively annotated and written in an accessible manner.

Admittedly he has created a good business with this knowledge and experience. I weigh this against my personal dislike of all the hucksters involved with osteoporosis....the 'Dr's who have no medical degrees but instead, for example, a PhD in anthropology, or the physical therapists who somehow have 'doctoral' degrees the basis for which I still cannot figure out.

So when push comes to shove, I rely on Dr. M's Great Bones. So I am wondering whether you have found helpful his info about biomarkers? And has this impacted your present approach?

Who advised you to go on Alendronate post-prolia v Reclast because of your CTX score? And did that same practitioner also advise about switching to Reclast at some point when indicated by CTX numbers?

My personal concern is my hips not my spine, which is normal (at least what can be read, apparently there is osteoarthritis at some places and this fools you into thinking it is density) so I do not know whether my current approach and understandings will be helpful to you. Your last DEXA score was not too bad and you have another coming up soon.

My sense is that biomarkers are best used to help know whether treatment is working in between DEXA scans. Like you, I am in a position of looking at CTX numbers more for diagnostic purposes.....should I go back on Alondrenate with a hip DEXA of -2.6?

Right now I am choosing to go on a drug holiday because my CTX and P1NP are within guideline that Dr. M likes. I am also thinking if I need medication, I would prefer to look at anabólics and give them a good chance without the influences of bisphonates.

I am also upping my game on nutrition and supps (the collagen I have started has resulted in phenomenal benefits to my 75 year old skin but have no idea yet what its impact might be on my osteoporosis) AND targeted exercise. I am also considering taking a REMs. I am not a good candidate for HRT but if I was I would be looking closely at this alternative.

Meanwhile, I have a potentially serious medical condition that still needs sorting out..... lots of tests, potential tests, and opinions. Takes lots of time and energy.

Good luck and please continue to share your thinking on how you approach your situation. It is helpful to all of us.

Jump to this post


Replies to "@awesomemomx2 We are all try but due diligence is often not enough in this arena. It..."

@rjd
In your comment you say " Alas, I did to go to medical school" . Can you clarify. I believe you meant to say I did not go to medical school. I just want to clarify, please. I chose to go on Alendronate initially rather than going on ReClast or Zoledronic Acid because I read resource articles , info from the connect, and Dr. M 's book as well information from his consult that your CTX should be at 200 before getting ReClast. I also discussed this my endocrinologist who agreed with that understanding. I had such a low CTX below 50 I figured it would not do any good at the point I discontinued Prolia. I was hoping the Alendronate would keep the CTX in check . Besides no one can say for certain exactly how long the Prolia remains working. And certainly not without doing ongoing CTX testing. Unfortunately, I have no idea how long it was at below 50. Now I am having a tooth and jaw issue so I am very concerned, especially since my CTX was below 50 and I don't know for how long. Even though my CTX is above 200 now, I did not want to complicate my mouth issue by going on ReClast. Consequently I am in a holding pattern with the current regimen. FYI, I do use Dr. M's collagen with Fortibone regularly whether or not it is helping I can not say. I hope so. I agree that it is important that we all continue to share info. It is really impactful.

@rjd I am new to this site but have been reading several replies with you, @windyshores and @formisc. I had my first Prolia shot in June, 2025 with my Endocrinologist, after being on Alendronate for 2 1/2 years prior. I wasn't told about any of the side effects, just that it was an injection every 6 months. I thought, that would be great instead of taking Alendronate every week. A few days after receiving the shot, I started getting pains in my right thigh/hip area and thought it was due to getting ready for a family reunion 5 days later. Well, come the day we left, I couldn't even put weight on my right side, and the pain was getting worst and could barely walk. I was trying to figure out what I had done differently to cause such pain. Then remembered the shot so I pulled it up on phone during travel, and sure enough, thigh pain was the first thing that I saw as a side effect. So, come December, when I was to get my 2nd shot, I told them I didn't want to continue with Prolia, so she put me back on Alendronate. With all this turmoil, I ended up finding a new Endo Dr. and she told me stop taking the Alendronate.

Now, I'm concerned about rebound with not being on anything now. With asking questions on other websites of 2 1/2 yrs on Alendronate, 1 shot of Prolia, back on Alendronate for 1 month and then not taking anything since January 2026, it looks like I'll be okay but I'm still scared. Any insight you have would be appreciated. Thanks in advance!