Exercise Oncology...what say you?

Posted by handera @handera, Jul 6 8:27am

Ran the July 4th Atlanta PeachTree 10K, along with 52,000 other participants.

What types of exercise, weekly regularity and for how long have you implemented additional exercise, since being diagnosed with PCa?

Have you observed any measurable benefits since implementing your post diagnosis exercise efforts?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

Yes, I'm with you. I prefer exercise integrated into my daily life as much as possible (walking to the grocery store, taking my grandpuppy out, mowing the lawn with a pushmower, clearing snow, etc) over exercise that's a separate thing you put on funny clothes for. Some people are gym rats and love that stuff, but I stick with it better when when it's organic.

REPLY
Profile picture for northoftheborder @northoftheborder

Yes, I'm with you. I prefer exercise integrated into my daily life as much as possible (walking to the grocery store, taking my grandpuppy out, mowing the lawn with a pushmower, clearing snow, etc) over exercise that's a separate thing you put on funny clothes for. Some people are gym rats and love that stuff, but I stick with it better when when it's organic.

Jump to this post

The good news: Yesterday, 3 weeks after HDR Brachy and a month after starting Xtandi (plus another Eligard injection), I worked up to about 90% of my weightlifting routine. That is, about 90% of what I was lifting a month ago.

The bad news: I took 3 naps yesterday, and was in bed by 8:30 p.m.

Apparently I also took two morning showers, because I had forgotten that I already took one.

I'm more-or-less OK until 11 a.m., then it's Drowsyville.

But I'm going to keep moving.

REPLY

One of those that didn't do Space Ore during salvage (wish I had) and exercised from diagnosis 2.5 years ago post RP through salvage up to a point and currently finishing ADT in a week. What I noticed is it helped me keep my weight down, got me outside into the state forest which is my peaceful place while connecting me with others, only gained 5 lbs. over 6 months and helped with ADT depression. I had to push myself out of the easy chair knowing I would feel better after exercising which I usually did.
Lessons learned: Switched to an E-mtb which helped moderate my efforts when needed and allowed me to keep up with my peeps. Managed my efforts using a heartrate monitor staying in aerobic zones, going too hard made me too tired to be consistent. No more than 3 days in a row, too tiring. And honored my fatigue taking additional days off as needed. Hope this helps.

REPLY
Profile picture for bluegill @bluegill

The good news: Yesterday, 3 weeks after HDR Brachy and a month after starting Xtandi (plus another Eligard injection), I worked up to about 90% of my weightlifting routine. That is, about 90% of what I was lifting a month ago.

The bad news: I took 3 naps yesterday, and was in bed by 8:30 p.m.

Apparently I also took two morning showers, because I had forgotten that I already took one.

I'm more-or-less OK until 11 a.m., then it's Drowsyville.

But I'm going to keep moving.

Jump to this post

Xtandi (Enzalutamide) causes severe fatigue problems for some people. Switching to Nubeqa (Darolutamide) Eliminates that problem For most people, And it works just as well. It also doesn’t pass the blood brain barrier so it has no effect on your memory.

I may take a 20 minute nap in the afternoon every few days But I stay up till midnight and get up right around 6:30 AM. I use a timer so my naps don’t go over 25 minutes and it usually really refreshes me. I am on Orgovyx and Nubeqa, and at 77 I don’t have much fatigue.

Talk to your doctor, see what he/she thinks after presenting your information.

REPLY

I exercise daily for other medical conditions as I have a blood cancer as well as diagnosed with intermediate prostate cancer 3 years ago… I have not treated the prostate cancer yet as I am already taking chemo pills daily for the blood issue…
I bike a short distance but vigorous ride daily in the morning and swim laps ~2000 yards at a health club as well.., I know this helps my blood issue, but will find out soon if my prostate cancer has progressed… Will be getting a PSMA Pet scan in August… I will have to be very careful if/when choosing any treatment for PCa..
In my case, exercise makes me feel really good despite my medical conditions…

REPLY
Profile picture for dale1k @dale1k

I exercise daily for other medical conditions as I have a blood cancer as well as diagnosed with intermediate prostate cancer 3 years ago… I have not treated the prostate cancer yet as I am already taking chemo pills daily for the blood issue…
I bike a short distance but vigorous ride daily in the morning and swim laps ~2000 yards at a health club as well.., I know this helps my blood issue, but will find out soon if my prostate cancer has progressed… Will be getting a PSMA Pet scan in August… I will have to be very careful if/when choosing any treatment for PCa..
In my case, exercise makes me feel really good despite my medical conditions…

Jump to this post

"In my case, exercise makes me feel really good despite my medical conditions… "

That's exactly it. In the end, whether exercise actually delays cancer progression or not is irrelevant to the decision, since we *know* it mitigates side-effects and improves quality of life.

There's little downside, as long as you're safe to do it (e.g. under medical supervision if you have a heart condition) and don't OVERdo it (ADT is very unforgiving of overexertion, as we all discover sooner or later).

REPLY
Profile picture for kujhawk1978 @kujhawk1978

Like others, have seen and read literature on exercise and PCa.

First thought, does exercise play a role in "preventing" or "reducing" one's chance of joining this club? Study of one, no, I have been active all my life, played multiple sports in high schools, 22 years in the Army so ran, lifted weights, played basketball, played gold (I walked, no cart) swam, went skiing, hiked in the mountains... After I retired, what changed, nothing. Last year my gym reported out I had visited 270 times, each visit was 45-60 minutes on the indoor bike, weights and 1000 meters swimming. For the 5th year in a row, I rode in the Garmin Unbound, a 50+ gravel bike ride in the Flint Hills of Kansas near Emporia.

And yet, there I was 23 January 2014, my urologist reviewing the TRUS biopsy report with me.

2nd thought, can exercise mitigate the side effects of PCa treatment, study of one, yes, to a degree. I am not sure it made a darn bit of difference in hot flashes, genitalia shrinkage...Perhaps I would have gained more weight when no T sunk my metabolism!!

What I think is exercise plays a role in one's CV health, bone health and a host of other systems which all of us can benefit from. I have read through literature which talks about the role exercise plays in our immune system systems (like liture on its role in testosterone) and that may be a factor as a stronger immune system may better fight off PCa in its weakened state brought on by treatments.

Again, study of one, but high risk, GS 8, GG 4, 18 months to BCR, rapid PSADT and PSAV...yet, 11+ years, here I am, three of those 11 on treatment, the other eight plus off. As I type, 15 months since my last treatment.

Kevin

Jump to this post

What is PSAV?

REPLY
Profile picture for handera @handera

My comment to yours was really “tongue-in-cheek”…I know we basically agree 👍

I also approach new information with a healthy level of skepticism…. probably because I spent the majority of my 45 year chemical engineering career doing research and development.

I’ve seen, first hand, how “science” can be manipulated for a whole host of reasons…scientists have biases (usually a product of their presuppositions), don’t let anyone try to convince you otherwise 🤔

I am, by no means, advocating that “exercise oncology” is the absolute “end all and be all” regarding PCa treatment.

That said, in my review of scores of medical research studies and probably hundreds of video presentations, regarding the many aspects of vigorous exercise, I am convinced there is much more solid science to the implementation of this “exercise treatment”, as it relates to slowing the progression of prostate cancer (with little downside), as compared to anything one cares to put in their mouth and swallow…just my studied opinion.

Obviously RCT’s are preferred reading; but when it comes to observational studies, the evidence is legion…literally hundreds of studies show evidence of benefit.

Rather than boring folks with a detailed list, I’ll refer to a recent February 2024 review that narrowed the list to the best studies….for those so inclined to read such information.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10854832/
All the best!

Jump to this post

Thanks for posting this study… So there is no definitive conclusion, but I’ll certainly continue to exercise as long as I can anyway..

REPLY
Profile picture for jeff Marchi @jeffmarc

Xtandi (Enzalutamide) causes severe fatigue problems for some people. Switching to Nubeqa (Darolutamide) Eliminates that problem For most people, And it works just as well. It also doesn’t pass the blood brain barrier so it has no effect on your memory.

I may take a 20 minute nap in the afternoon every few days But I stay up till midnight and get up right around 6:30 AM. I use a timer so my naps don’t go over 25 minutes and it usually really refreshes me. I am on Orgovyx and Nubeqa, and at 77 I don’t have much fatigue.

Talk to your doctor, see what he/she thinks after presenting your information.

Jump to this post

Jeff, does Darolutamide lower the testosterone like Eligard?

REPLY
Profile picture for dale1k @dale1k

Thanks for posting this study… So there is no definitive conclusion, but I’ll certainly continue to exercise as long as I can anyway..

Jump to this post

Well, as mentioned earlier, there was a conclusion in the ERASE randomized clinical trial (published August 2021), cited below:

“The ERASE trial demonstrated that HIIT increased cardiorespiratory fitness levels and decreased PSA levels, PSA velocity, and prostate cancer cell growth in men with localized prostate cancer who were under active surveillance.“
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaoncology/fullarticle/2783273
One can choose not to believe it or have another reason to be skeptical regarding its clear conclusion, but its implementation is working in my case and that's good enough for me.

I was diagnosed with low risk Gleason 3+4 in October 2023.

I'm not saying it will work for everyone (or even the majority of low risk PCa men)...everyone chooses the treatment for which they are most comfortable implementing...and I'm completely comfortable (as is my urologist) with my exercise oncology protocol. I plan to stick with it.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.