My oncologist uses a nurse practitioner

Posted by wdene @wdene, 5 days ago

Do you see a nurse practitioner sometimes instead of Dr oncologist on scheduled visits. I’m uncomfortable with this. Your experience please.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

@chippydoo

NP's and PA's from my personal experience train in a specialty and are knowledgeable in that area. The physician mine worked for is considered one of the best in the county in his specialty and the NP and PA wouldn't be with him if they weren't that good in that respective lane. Sorry you had a bad experience with them. I and my wife have had doctors misdiagnose conditions too.

Jump to this post

I think the main point to be considered is the level of training and expertise of a medical provider for a specific situation.
An MD is a medical doctor who can go on to become a Specialist in a specific area. They do additional training and are board certified.
PAs have generalized course work and do not have coursework for specialized areas of medicine during their schooling. They can chose to work in a specific area and acquire on the job experience. NPs can be more specialized, but they are far from a Board-certified Specialist
Expertise matters. For example, last year my cancer pulmonologist referred me for a consult with interstitial disease pulmonologist regarding best choice in fibrosis drugs. The desk set me up with NP and I said no, I need MD because I have both lung cancer and pulmonary fibrosis. The new MD Specialist reviewed all my tests, scans, stress tests for last 3 years. He then gave me a diagnosis saying I had at least 3 reasons for shortness of breath. And he decided I should go on Oxygen and hold back on fibrosis drug. No NP/PA could do that.
It is a logical choice. If one is a "vanilla" follow-up case, that is one thing, but people with complex conditions where treatment choices need to be strategic, one cannot expect a person of significantly less training/experience to provide sufficient level of care.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.