loriesco,
you might find this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqY7Bm9HiD0&list=PLRwK07HRBX0AacaOM-hn_Ut12jpdDYSUj&index=5 interesting. At26,30 in Bilezikian's presentation there is a chart reflecting the percentage rise from baseline for CTX and P1NP. We don't have your baseline before Reclast so we can't compare %ages. Ideally you'd have taken a P1NP one month in from starting Tymlos. At twelve months your P1NP would have lowered from the first month high. So we can't do comparisons (confidently). One year of Reclast would have lowered both CTX and P1NP from whatever your original base was.
I find it interesting that CTX has risen as much as it has within the year after Reclast.
I suspect that the doubling of the P1NP at twelve month is partially a reflection of the delayed PTH response after bisphosphonate. But that doubling has to be seen as good.
Thanks for posting your numbers. I'll be curious to see other responses to your post.