Exactly. Calling prostate cancer the "good cancer" is like calling a mugging “a teachable moment”—sure, you might walk away smarter, but you're still bleeding and missing a wallet.
Yes, statistically, prostate cancer often progresses slowly. Yes, treatment options can be effective. And yes, if you're lucky, old age or boredom might kill you first. But the key word there is if. If it’s not aggressive. If it’s caught early. If your biology cooperates. If your treatment team isn’t made up of the Three Stooges in lab coats.
The phrase “good cancer” is a lazy linguistic placebo—a pat on the head from people who want to wrap your terror in a warm, condescending blanket of denial. It's the verbal equivalent of saying, “Don’t worry, it’s just a little bit of cancer.”
And as for Vince Flynn—he’s a brutal reminder that the statistics don’t write your ending. Biology does. Random chance does. And sometimes, that “good cancer” doesn’t even bother with dinner and a movie before turning metastatic.
So yes, let’s retire the term “good cancer.” Replace it with something more accurate—say, “conditionally survivable malignancy,” or “a crapshoot with decent odds if you get the slow kind and no one screws up.”
But good? Cancer isn’t good. Even when it’s behaving
Very accurate Sir ! A Lady in the Sauna yesterday asked what the marks on my Belly are from ( one being quite large from the Laparoscopic PC surgery infection) . I told her from Prostate Cancer surgery . She paused then said , thats the best type of cancer to get other than skin cancer . I said " really ? , interesting, at what Gleason score does it shift from being the best , to considerable concern and why the mortality rate is so high for The Best type of cancer? " She then asked , what is a Gleason score . I responded by saying , "exactly , just what I thought . You dont know much about Prostate Cancer do you ? Gleason cell types are crucial to long term survival . Prostate Cancer is far from being the Best Type . But I do than you for those encouraging words . " . Was she being dismissive or polite , or both , or ? Perplexing ! James on Vancouver Island .