In this case, may I suggest that it seems we have a difference of opinion.
The “gold standard.” That magical phrase physicians utter with the same reverence as one might invoke the Holy Grail or a particularly solid IKEA warranty. It’s the safe space of clinical inertia—comforting, defensible, and conveniently free of pesky nuance.
From my perspective, it appears that some doctors seem to believe that medicine is best practiced like cooking from a box mix: just add water (or ADT) and voilà, you have Evidence-Based Excellence™. Ask a question? Receive a number. Challenge the dogma? Watch the eyebrows raise and the malpractice risk calculator start whirring in the background.
As for eloquence—don’t sell yourself short. If clear thinking and a willingness to critically evaluate medical orthodoxy don’t qualify as eloquence, then we may as well hand the microphone to the nearest prescription pad and call it keynote speaker.
Your surgeon prescribing two years of ADT when your RO floated a 3–5% benefit? Classic. It’s like being told to wear a raincoat in the Sahara just in case. And yet, somehow, questioning this earns you a suspicious glance, as if you’ve suggested treating cancer with moonlight and essential oils.
But I hear you. When you're in a fight, you fight. It’s just unfortunate that sometimes you're not sure if your corner is shouting strategy or just reading off a flowchart in Latin.
Still, here's to the rebels, the researchers, and those of us who politely raise our hand in the temple of "standard care" and ask, “Yes, but… why?”
This exchange brought several posts from a 2024 thread to mind. It was, of course, created by "messieurs de la confrérie maudite" (not all shown sequentially below):
"strutt52 | @cstrutt52 | Aug 23, 2024
There is an old medical adage that I try to remember when dealing with suspect conditions I might have. "When patients hear hooves, they tend to think zebras." Meaning, that most of the time it is just a horse, and the not more exotic troublesome diseases that can affect us."
"northoftheborder | @northoftheborder | Aug 23, 2024
In reply to @cstrutt52 "There is an old medical adage that I try to remember when dealing with suspect conditions..." + (show)
In my case, I originally thought the hooves were horses and they turned out to be zebras. 😕"
"stevecando54 | @stevecando54 | Aug 23, 2024
In reply to @scottbeammeup "I think men are just as attuned to our bodies as women, but we are better..." + (show)
Being stubborn got me into this mess,, oh well, little late now..Best to all"
"northoftheborder | @northoftheborder | Aug 23, 2024
In reply to @heavyphil "After all you’ve gone thru and all the various surgeries, procedures and drugs how could you..." + (show)
Yes, I agree. It's very important to self-monitor. I think the disorder is when it becomes excessive and dysfunctional, just like washing your hands is good, but continuing until your hands are raw and bleeding isn't. It's tricky with cancer, because we always worry that the one thing we decide *not* to worry about will be the one that matters."
For better and for worse, when you have cancer, there is no such thing as an idle mind.
Bill