Surgeon missed the margins. 2nd surgery

Posted by freebird67 @freebird67, Apr 1, 2024

Good morning all,
Had lumpectomy 3-18 went back on 3-28 thinking surgeon would release me to oncologist but No ! She told me they missed the margins. I was kinda dumbfounded at first, she explained to me that they have to go back in and cut more and scrap. Then asked me.... do you have a problem with this ? Of course I have a problem with this, who wouldn't ! She just told me cancer cells were pushing on the margin. So I'm headed for another surgery this Friday.
I'm loosing faith in the medical system fast. The nurse came in to schedule my surgery and said it happens like no big deal.
So I guess my question is, have any of you gone through this ? Did it change anything for you ? I did do some research about it and didn't like what I read. But have no choice on this. Thank you and
Have a blessed day

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Breast Cancer Support Group.

@einnoc

"I'm losing faith in the medical system fast. The nurse came in to schedule my surgery and said it happens like no big deal."
"I was upset mostly because I wasn't told this could happen.
Communication could be better."
"Then asked me.... do you have a problem with this ? Of course I have a problem with this, who wouldn't !"
"You have to be your own advocate."
*******
The quotes above resonate(d) with me. I have lost so much faith in the medical system. I grew up at a time when doctors made house calls. I believed that doctors had a "higher calling" than just collecting $ for office visits. I thought that they cared whether you lived or died, and they would not intentionally withhold information from you that you needed to know in order to be prepared for the worst, if, God forbid, it happened. I didn't expect that an oncologist would employ a bevy of P.A.'s ("the minions," I all them) whose entire job seemed to be keeping you from ever having a face-to-face discussion with The Man and giving you the message, over and over and over, for 17 months, that "the patient portal is not the appropriate forum for this question. You should wait until you have a face-to-face meeting with the ocologist," which, of course, they were probably instructed to make sure it did not happen. I was only seen by my oncologist in Illinois 2 times in 8 months, and, during those brief visits, he never answered the questions I had nor told the truth. I asked about an oncotype and his curt response (Dec. 2021) was "You don't need one." That remark, alone, is debatable in light of the fact that, when I finally got one from my 3rd oncologist in 2023, it was 29. When I asked about the side effects of Anastrozole, his response (in writing, since he never saw me in person if he could avoid it) was, "The only side effect of taking Anastrozole is a little stiffness in your hands and fingers first thing in the morning, and it goes away when you quit taking it." (Wrong!) I also question not giving the patient a chance to recover from a seroma, less than a week out of surgery, before putting them on Anastrozole, and having them take it throughout the 33 radiation treatments. Even the 33 radiation treatments, in retrospect, are questionable, since the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics told me, 3 days before I was to start the radiation, that they would not have radiated me at all, because, he said, "You're a woman in your 70s." (basically an age that they seem to feel is 1 foot in the grave.) (Try to maintain you are only 69 at the oldest, because, after that, it is questionable whether or not you'll be viewed as a viable patient with some life left in you. The "be your own advocate" is the most telling, because I have had to be. Today's medical mantra seems to be YOYO: "You're On Your Own."

Jump to this post

@einnoc, totally agree with all you stated. Be Proactive Be your own Advocate Stay Strong cuz YOYO Blessings to you.

REPLY
@dlmdinia

My first lumpectomy included removal of 13 lymph nodes. The drain was a pain, and the recovery long and painful (the road vibrations while being in a car had me using hydrochodone). Exactly 4 weeks later I was back for a second lumpectomy because clear margins had not been achieved, and at the same time I had a port implanted for chemo (stage 3). The second surgery and recovery were a piece of cake, so I didn't mind as it was worth it for clear margins. It happens. I never blamed my surgeon.

Jump to this post

I am also having to return for a second surgery because of the pathology report from the first surgery showed the margins were not clear. I had a lumpectomy 3 weeks ago and am scheduled to have the second in 2 weeks. I have an amazing surgeon and I am looking at it this way…The surgeon has no way of knowing whether they have removed all the cancer cells because they don’t have pathologists with them in the operating room. I would think they do try to take as much margin as possible and because all breasts aren’t the same, such as with women with smaller breasts who don’t have as much tissue. I also am not blaming my surgeon. Things happen and you just have to feel lucky that they caught the problem and will take care of it

REPLY

That is rough. Sometimes the specimen is sent right to a pathologist before they sew you up. Then sometimes they do not. I hope they are able to get it all a 2nd time. I am praying for your surgeon.

REPLY
@sherry94

I am also having to return for a second surgery because of the pathology report from the first surgery showed the margins were not clear. I had a lumpectomy 3 weeks ago and am scheduled to have the second in 2 weeks. I have an amazing surgeon and I am looking at it this way…The surgeon has no way of knowing whether they have removed all the cancer cells because they don’t have pathologists with them in the operating room. I would think they do try to take as much margin as possible and because all breasts aren’t the same, such as with women with smaller breasts who don’t have as much tissue. I also am not blaming my surgeon. Things happen and you just have to feel lucky that they caught the problem and will take care of it

Jump to this post

I had to have a second surgery after my lumpectomy and reconstructive. My DCIS the margins were “missed” they were clear but needed them bigger. My IDC margins were clear. Reading the pathology report with PA and said margins were smaller than they like. Surgeon came in and said we’re having a second surgery. Very unexpected - but necessary. I had tears in my eyes.
I think it was done the next week. Took me longer to recover or get rid of the anesthesia.

REPLY

Yes, my first lumpectomy showed poor margins and along with DCIS they found invasive papillary cancer. So, about 4 weeks later, I had the second lumpectomy with clear, but close margins. So, now it’s whole breast radiation and then AIs. I’m thinking this is common with lumpectomies.

REPLY

For me, a lumpectomy was never really a choice. My funky tumor was big and only shrunk one half with chemo. So removing it with margins would have been greatly disfiguring. My small inherited bust size did it to me again!!!! I do know my surgeon had said i could still do it but the plastics dr may not have the best outcome.
I just pray margins will be better met at more facilities before the surgery is completed. Years ago, my dermatologist asked me if i would like to see my specimen he removed under a microscope. He also was a pathologist. He showed me the margins and what he cut what he did and how far from the actual center. Dense breasts and other things and it all seem to just be not perfect. It is quite possible they do the best they can at the time.
Best to all as you navigate this road. Aday at a time, the road opens again.

REPLY
@celestebradham

I had to have a second surgery after my lumpectomy and reconstructive. My DCIS the margins were “missed” they were clear but needed them bigger. My IDC margins were clear. Reading the pathology report with PA and said margins were smaller than they like. Surgeon came in and said we’re having a second surgery. Very unexpected - but necessary. I had tears in my eyes.
I think it was done the next week. Took me longer to recover or get rid of the anesthesia.

Jump to this post

Get a second opinion or different surgeon. Was this at the Mayo?

REPLY

I'm not so generous or forgiving. I would have been very upset, o.k. angry, if clean margins were missed. I would have been a traumatized mess. I'd also be looking at 2nd AND 3rd opinions, as well as possibly a new surgeon. I was stage 1 & had a lumpectomy with reconstruction in Feb 2025 and let me tell you, it took me months to schedule biopsy, MRI, and interview plastic surgeon, so having another surgery & recovery delays after all those delays would have definitely NOT left me with no hard feelings towards the surgeon and with no confidence in that surgeon. This is my life, not an oh well it happens let's cut you open again in a few weeks! But that's just me. I'm also surprised about all these lumpectomies without clear margins. Was breast reconstruction not an option? My surgeons told me it would be unlikely to miss clean margins since they could be overly generous in taking tissue out at the cancer site. Margins were clean. Three weeks of radiation over yesterday. Now Anastrozole started and I'm concerned about side effects, but my bone density scan came back with low risk. So I'm optimistic about that. The other side effects? I pray they are minimal.

REPLY
@flygirl747

Get a second opinion or different surgeon. Was this at the Mayo?

Jump to this post

What you said! I'm in the Texas Hill Country & I'd be running to MD Anderson for 2nd & 3rd opinions and for a new surgeon. I could not shrug off those missed margins or weeks more of uncertainty & pain & give that doc more of my finite life time or money. Yes, maybe it's "not uncommon" but that doesn't mean it should have occurred. Yes, I knew it was a slim possibility but they sold it to me as highly unlikely.

REPLY
@flygirl747

Get a second opinion or different surgeon. Was this at the Mayo?

Jump to this post

Not at Mayo, in Houston at MD Anderson. I understand that I needed margins to be larger. Second surgery also had plastic surgeon there again. My breasts look very good. Everything was scheduled for me and they worked around me having to travel to Houston .

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.