Surgery? Radiation? Can I have an independent suggestion?

Posted by hanscasteels @hanscasteels, Dec 19, 2024

As a Canadian, I apologize in advance for my self-centered question. I have done all the preliminaries and now must make a choice. When asking urologists, they’d advocate for “cutting”. When talking to radiation oncologists, they’d say “radiate” - statistically, the odds are equal or better, and the side effects - well, perhaps, eventually, you might have to deal with those. Which leaves me, as someone reluctant to understand issues related to cancer that I never wanted to know, to make a decision.

In short, here are the parameters: over 4 months, PSA readings of 26, 21, and 25. Biopsy showed cancer in the left nodule, Gleason 3+4 in 5 out of 12 cores. Cribriform and suspected perineurial invasion. Bone scan and CT scan showed no metastasis. PET scan shows a significant uptake (3.7) in the prostate but also, no metastatic activity, except for a minuscule uptake in L4 lumber (but judged to be benign). That doesn’t eliminate microscopic events, I suppose. Also had a prior appetizer of a heart attack and had CABG (9 bypasses).

The question now: what would be an optional approach for me, specifically. ChatGPT says a short course of agonist/antagonist ADT, Brachytherapy, and EBRT. The urologist says “if you want it gone, call me”. The radiologist says “the isotopes are at your service”. How on earth can I make an informed decision that’s best for me if everyone advocates for what they do/know as the best approach?I suspect some answers might be - it depends what consequences you want to deal with - granted. But medically, what gives me the best chance to conquer this, well, shit?

Where would you take it?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

@chamblee54

I feel your pain. Everyone advocates their specialty.
I simply studied the most likely side effects and picked the one with best likelihood of quality of life.
I got three opinions.
I wasn’t in a hurry to be rushed. When I did make a decision I had confidence it would be best for me. I tried and left emotion out of it and looked at risks.
One last thing , I got an Artera AI test and it suggested treatment based on my data. And it matched what I picked.

Jump to this post

What did you select for treatment?

REPLY
@packman7

What did you select for treatment?

Jump to this post

I went with beam radiation and 4 mos ADT , but after 3 months on ADT my Artera AI test suggested no ADT so I stopped a month later. Under Dr supervision

REPLY
@packman7

I appreciate your comments !
I’m also trying to decide on a treatment at Mayo .
Gleason 3+3 /6
8/12 cores positive for cancer
PSA 16
The team says I shouldn’t do surveillance given positive cores percentage and PSA .
I seem to be leading in your direction of surgery however would like other choices that are proven options . Agree with the comment that the only way to be sure in to remove prostate and identify in actuality what type .
I would ask , What is the most predictable treatment with the best quality of life ???????

Jump to this post

Everyone that did the radioactive seeds plus some radiation ( external) are really Cancer free . One friend had some incontinence but it was temporary and he is still alive and his cancer free did this treatment in 2013 for Darrell my friend so yeah you’re just getting started on. I’m probably PSA. My PSA is probably over 60 right now which I know some can go over 100 but you’re just getting started. Keep fighting ! trust God prayer a lot.

REPLY
@hanscasteels

I’d rather say I have been on belly- button watch. The pace of activity has been very slow, it seems that none of this “is a big deal” - the first urologist I saw said “everything is fine” despite. PSA reading of 26… it’s been shit show, frankly. The oncologist yesterday said he’d refer me to someone else, cardiologist is involved because I involved them… it’s been very colloquial and provincial This is when I was told that, while the PET scan shows it localized, the lesion is highly aggressive and high risk. It’s mind boggling. No team structure. Individuals making individual decisions….

Jump to this post

handscasteels Where and how did you get a PSA PET CT Scan with your Gleason Score ?
I find Urologists in Ontario very reluctant to request a PSA PET CT Scan unless it is advanced cancer .

REPLY
@clandeboye1

handscasteels Where and how did you get a PSA PET CT Scan with your Gleason Score ?
I find Urologists in Ontario very reluctant to request a PSA PET CT Scan unless it is advanced cancer .

Jump to this post

In my case, I learned about my Gleason score 7 (3 + 4) after my urologist took 12 (or 14) specimens last Feb 14, at Mackenzie Health Richmond Hill, Ontario. He ordered a "Nuclear Medicine whole body bone scan + SPECT + CT X2 Panel" -- finding "No scintigraphic evidence of metastatic disease; Rule out metastatic disease from prostate." CT scan of my pelvis and abdomen will be on Feb 28. I sure hope for a similar finding of no metastatic disease. My urologist referred me to an oncologist at Sunnybrook Hospital -- a teaching (research) hospital affiliated with the University of Toronto. My initial consultation with Sunnybrook is tentatively set for March 6, but they will find an earlier date if possible and let me know. (As another poster indicated in this discussion thread, if a case is serious it will be seen sooner than usual.) I am 68, thinking of prostatectomy, but after reading the above posts, I am reconsidering if I should instead opt for SBRT. I will discuss with the oncologist.

REPLY

@vircet If you consider SBRT 5 Treatments Mon - Wed - Fri and Mon - Wed the following week .
Inquire abouut Monotherapy SBRT - NO HORMONE ADT SHIT , The side effects are worse than the
cancer . Your quality of life would change immensely . I am G 3+4 = 7 and on active surveillance . I met
Dr. Bayley , Radiation Oncologist at Sunnybrook . Also an Oncologist & Urologist at Princess Margaret .
PLEASE KEEP ME POSTED ON YOUR SUNNYBROOK EXPERIENCE .

REPLY
@clandeboye1

handscasteels Where and how did you get a PSA PET CT Scan with your Gleason Score ?
I find Urologists in Ontario very reluctant to request a PSA PET CT Scan unless it is advanced cancer .

Jump to this post

Apparently one has to "qualify" in Ontario. PSA has to be < 20, Gleason score is irrelevant. This tumor also has cribriform cells as well as perineural invasion. Hence was considered risky, and voilà, I qualified. There are only a few hospitals that offer this scan - if you're close to London, chose that one (London health Sciences).2week wait time vs. 4=6 weeks anywhere else,

REPLY
@hanscasteels

Apparently one has to "qualify" in Ontario. PSA has to be < 20, Gleason score is irrelevant. This tumor also has cribriform cells as well as perineural invasion. Hence was considered risky, and voilà, I qualified. There are only a few hospitals that offer this scan - if you're close to London, chose that one (London health Sciences).2week wait time vs. 4=6 weeks anywhere else,

Jump to this post

@hanscasteels . Thanks for your response .
I was aware of the OHIP qualifications -- My issue is finding a Urologist to refer me for a "Private Pay Test " -- No success with four so far . One in St. Catharines & Three in Toronto which includes Princess Margaret Hospital and the Head of Urology at another major Toronto Hospital . There are several private clinics in Toronto , tthe cost is $ 5000.00 -- However they require a referral .

REPLY
@clandeboye1

@hanscasteels . Thanks for your response .
I was aware of the OHIP qualifications -- My issue is finding a Urologist to refer me for a "Private Pay Test " -- No success with four so far . One in St. Catharines & Three in Toronto which includes Princess Margaret Hospital and the Head of Urology at another major Toronto Hospital . There are several private clinics in Toronto , tthe cost is $ 5000.00 -- However they require a referral .

Jump to this post

It typically is an oncologist that will refer you. Not a urologist.

REPLY
@hanscasteels

It typically is an oncologist that will refer you. Not a urologist.

Jump to this post

hanscasteels The Private Clinics in Mississauga will accept a referral from a GP or a Oncologist -- It's all about money. My GP tells me to get a referral from my Oncologist ( passing the buck )

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.