Surgery for thoracic outlet syndrome
Hello
Has anyone had surgery for thoracic outlet syndrome?
I have been to three tos specialists and they all have different approaches even wrt surgery. One removing some muscle, another removing first rib bone and muscle via clavicle area and another first bone and muscle via under armpit area. My tos is more of neurogenic and intermittent vascular. I have also heard mostly pt and therapists discouraging surgery as well as cases of no resolution even after surgery.
My immediate functional issue from it is pressure build up from the area to neck and head currently.
With added complication with cervical spondylosis and left lung removal from years ago.
Thanks in advance.
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Bones, Joints & Muscles Support Group.
Hello,
My journey that started with TOS has gotten now much more complicated with cranio cervical instability, cervical dystonia, occipital neuralgia…etc.
Since you mention brain fog, I just wanted to share that about a year after TOS, i started having it also along with lightheadedness and heaviness at the occipital area. One doctor I saw for my symptoms who was familiar with CCI said that TOS is caused by cervical issues which tightens the scalene and etc sometimes. Having said that since only mild disc bulge at c5/6 with bone spurs was detected via MRI at the time, it’s hard to pinpoint. Many unhelpful things happened, chiro, acupressure, numerous pts and in the end, I currently have found that there are more things going on. CCI with translational bai 5-6 mm, mild cervical and thoracic scoliosis as well as sacroilitis with uneven pelvis. Without going into too much details of my complicated journey in 2024, just wanted to add checking for any cervical issues may be beneficial?
I also found out that being hyper mobile predisposes you to TOS…
Best wishes to you
Thank you Jennifer as always for your insight and care.
@closer0043 You do have a lot on your plate. It’s a decision you can’t change after the fact and surgery will create scar tissue. My PT will mobilize my first ribs that get hiked up from the tight muscles which helps and the MFR work too. Do you think trying MFR before heading to surgery could help? I do know there are a lot of variations of TOS. My hands used to turn blue and get cold which doesn’t happen now, but over exertion can trigger some of that to a lesser degree, but I know some PT things that I can do to help. TOS is controversial among doctors and easily misunderstood. Are you going to consider other opinions? Mayo would be a good place to evaluate TOS if that is within your reach.
@snowmass I am similar to you in that I had cervical spine issues along with TOS and pelvis misalignment. There are ways to realign the pelvis. All of that affects everything else. My PT was addressing all of that and full body alignment with myofascial release. Have you tried anything like that?
@jenniferhunter
PTs are afraid to work on me with CCI symptoms which has become more debilitating as it is progressing than TOS in 2024. Unfortunately, there are about 5 neurosurgeons in US who are familiar with CCI when it falls into the grey area of not so severe where you need c0-1/2 fusion right away. There is one Regenexx location, Centeno & Schultz Clinic, in Denver, CO that does bone marrow concentrate/PRP to address CCI issues due to ligament laxity (many from auto accidents/sports accidents/hEDS) using procedure called PICL (Percutaneous Implantation of the CCJ Ligaments) which I am waiting on in April 2025 as a non-invasive treatment next to fusion surgery unfortunately because my recent botox treatment ( Jan 2025) for cervical dystonia made my CCI so much worse that I need to wait for it to wear off (3 months) before PICL. I am seeing a visiting MFR lady who has worked on dura flow because my nervous system is so hyper being upright with CCI. I will ask her about pelvis treatment next time. There is no guarantee that PICL will work either since these treatments are individual based ( your stem cell count/system wide inflammation level/no injuries during the long months of healing, 3 to 6 months to a year) but some had success so that is my hope.
It's really unfortunate how unfamiliar medical population is from radiologists to neurosurgeons...wrt upper cervical issues...losing time/functionality while passed around so many consults. This has been just how it is for me. Hope you are well Jennifer.
Thanks for the CCI information. Another malady I will have to investigate as it does explain a lot of my symptoms. However, my TOS is unmistakable. I may have both issues going on though. My right arm is so bad though that I can’t even search my phone for more than 15 seconds on the phone holder in my car without having to rest my arm. I am most likely going to get the surgery for TOS. I have pretty good hope that it will help my arm regain strength to be able to return to baseball. If it helps the brain fog and dizziness (which is way less frequent since I stopped throwing) that would be an added bonus. If it doesn’t, I will look into CCI. Here is my worst area of my cervical MRI report:
C5-6: The disc is degenerated with loss of height and T2 weighted signal. There is diffuse posterior protrusion with narrowing of the thecal sac but no mass effect upon the cord. The posterior facets are degenerated with narrowing of the neural foramina.
I definitely have a bulging disc here, but every doctor says it’s not serious enough for surgery or to cause most of my neurological symptoms. So I’m hoping it’s the TOS causing them, and the rib removal will solve the issue.
My TOS imaging revealed compression on subclavian vein and EMG test also showed slowed signal as well as cubitel tunnel syndrome. Saw three doctors, Cedars, UCLA and USC. First offered scalenectomy and second offered rib resection and scalenectomy and the third explained the usual procedure for rib resection and scalenectomy but also offered referral to Mass Gen Hospital to see Dr Donahue.
I also had mild C5-6 disc bulge with osteophyte and mild height loss at the time of TOS diagnosis which spine doctors also said that it is non-surgical and not the cause for pain and neurological symptoms . Within one month from scalene block injection on anterior and middle scales on the right, I started having mild lightheadedness, brain fog and tinnitus.
Thru my numerous imaging reports, I learned that what the report says or what the dr sees are very subjective to their experience and training. For example, some would say mild and another severe, not to mention normal vs compression especially when it comes to very specific conditions. I won't bore you with my story but what concerns me is your mention of how dizziness/brain fog lessening with stopping the throwing. Have you tried botox or scalene block injection for the symptoms relief of TOS if you are not hyper mobile (botox is not good for hyper mobile)? Mass Gen Hospital has you do botox instead of scalene block injection because it is more definitive due to the duration of affect to sort of confirm the success outcome of your surgery if deemed necessary I believe. (Unfortunately the wait for MGH is like a year, they do a lot of revision surgeries as well)
One other thing, I have had two scalene block injections (usually local anesthetic and steroid) by two different providers. One was anterior and middle scalenes only and the other was the 2 scalene muscle, subclavius and pect minor all at once. Interestingly, the latter, gave me more relief. Sometimes the TOS surgery involves pect minor release as well...
Hope this helps.
@closer0043 Please let me know if you would like more info on CCI. It took me a very long time to hash thru due to the nature of not enough CCI for surgery but still debilitating and not enough specialists who are knowledgeable...among the neurosurgeons. You can also look into Facebook support groups for additional info. Same with TOS,