← Return to Is it always a good idea to not contradict a person with dementia?

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
@bayviewgal

bclane I agree with you and how you don't understand asking direct questions. If we don't ask questions how are we suppose to know what they want? Because there are times of clarity (with my husband). If he seems confused about the question I'm asking, I will word it differently or maybe speak slower. When it comes to asking what he wants to drink or snack on, etc, I usually have to "show' him, and then it's a choice of 2 things and he looks more at ease with answering. This awful disease has been a struggle for both of us and I do everything I can to ease those struggles. There are times that the direct question I ask him, is if he knows my name and he looks confused, and more times than not, he will say 'umm no" and when I tell him he'll just say, OK and that's the end of that. I don't want to add to his confusion and remind him I'm his wife, but that's just me. Does it make me sad? Of course it does, but I know who I am and more importantly who HE is to me... my adorable, funny, handsome love of my life and will do everything I can for him!
Hugs and prayers to you

Jump to this post


Replies to "bclane I agree with you and how you don't understand asking direct questions. If we don't..."

So far my husband has been okay with my reminding him we're married on the occasions he doesn't know who I am. Most of the time, he gives every indication of still knowing. I realize as the dementia progresses, that will probably change.

I'm sure it also depends on the personality of the person with dementia and the dynamic that existed between the caregiver and the person before dementia made its appearance. My husband has always been pretty easygoing, and he still is. The relationship was always on an equal footing, which isn't always the case with older couples. I would never have married a man who insisted on being the boss. I was a police officer for ten years, and you can't do that job by being subservient to males!

Anyway, now I think that previous dynamic helps because on the few occasions that my husband gets carried away about something or is insisting on doing something that could be potentially dangerous to him, I can tell him to knock it off or go to bed or whatever. When it's obvious that I've about had it, he listens and does what I tell him. I guess it's like dealing with a child in that respect. So far, that hasn't happened often, and it's a last resort when my stress level is about through the roof. Most of the time I can deal with him in a less bossy way. I really hope his personality stays like this because it's safer for him if he will do or not do what I tell him, but I know there's no guarantee of that. For all of us, it's just a day to day thing, I guess.