Truth about Total Knee Replacements

Posted by rickraleigh @rickraleigh, Jul 31, 2021

Your new knee will never feel as good as your original old one

For most people it takes a full year to get most of the benefits of the surgery

Many people experience a clicking sound when walking for years or forever after the surgery

You should do physical therapy for a year after the surgery to get the best range of motion results even though your therapist will discharge you after several months.

There are no studies which will tell you what activities you can do after TKR. Is doubles tennis OK? Golf? What you read online varies. There are no clear answers.

Many surgeons are finished with you after the surgery. If you have issues with the surgery's aftermath, they may not be that helpful.

The scar is big, and no amount of ointment (vitamin E, etc.) will substantially reduce it.

Good news: If you had bad knee problems before the surgery your knee will feel a lot better after the surgery.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Joint Replacements Support Group.

@anadarko

Neuropathy in my right foot has gotten much worse since I had a right TKR. Have you heard that can be a result of the TKR?

Jump to this post

I have needed a TKR for 2 years now, and it's finally scheduled for February 11th. I now have neuropathy in both feet that is as severe as (sometimes more so) the pain in my knees, which are bone on bone from the last MRI in April 2024. My pain management provider feels it is a result of limping around on 2 bad knees.

What helps the neuropath in your feet? I am on pregablin, and lamotrigine, which help some and oxy at times. As is true with chronic pain, nothing takes pain 100% away-but I am interested in something that will provide relief, as there is always room for improvement.

REPLY
@catmomma

I have needed a TKR for 2 years now, and it's finally scheduled for February 11th. I now have neuropathy in both feet that is as severe as (sometimes more so) the pain in my knees, which are bone on bone from the last MRI in April 2024. My pain management provider feels it is a result of limping around on 2 bad knees.

What helps the neuropath in your feet? I am on pregablin, and lamotrigine, which help some and oxy at times. As is true with chronic pain, nothing takes pain 100% away-but I am interested in something that will provide relief, as there is always room for improvement.

Jump to this post

I take no drugs for the neuropathy. Exercise helps.

REPLY
@ellerbracke

I had right TKR almost 3 years ago. No major problems, except permanent clicking noise with some motions. Had Arthritis, bone spur, torn Meniscus a year prior to TKR. Repair surgery with intense PT and exercise regimen after that did not change the pain. Would have been ok if I did not plan on living an active life, but every time I walked down an incline, or steps, intense pain. So TKR. After the usual course of pain/rehab/continued exercises the knee works very well. For me the surgery was worth it. Well, except for the well known kneeling issue. As in don’t do it.

Jump to this post

I read an NIH study about kneeling post TKR, it made sense to me, and at 10 months post surgery I think the NIH approach is working. The study followed two groups of TKR patients. One group did what came natural to them regarding kneeling (which basically means they did not kneel because it is painful and feels weird). The other group were instructed to kneel for increasing lengths of time (30 secs to 2 minutes), on increasingly harder surfaces, and after several months the group that was made to kneel tolerated kneeling by a meaningful percentage over the group that did what came natural to them regarding kneeling.

I’ve forced myself to try and kneel a few times a week (not nearly as much as the NIH group), and the more I kneel the less it is an issue. Don’t get me wrong, it is still something that I’d rather avoid, but I can now tolerate it when needed without freaking out. That was not the case when I started trying to kneel.

REPLY
@guitarlady

Jdth,
It's good to hear you've improved and are not so depressed. It's easy to get down when you don't feel right.

What food have you found that you enjoy post TKR? After my last one in '23, chicken noodle soup hit the spot. Other things looked good but I found I'd take one bite and get turned off. Rich things were a no-go for a long time. I lost some needed pounds, but it's not a happy way to do it, is it?

I have balance issues so am using a rollator anyway.

Jump to this post

I’m glad I’m not the only one who feels hungry but then just can’t eat. Yesterday I sent my husband for a flatbread with chicken and avacado. It tasted fresh. I’m craving mashed potatoes. He’s not a cook and thought a ham sandwich every day would be ok!!! I Jace tried to cook a bit, but I’m just not motivated do much. That’s what concerns me: I’m usually a go-getter. My PT says I’m expecting too much too soon. Thank you for commiserating!

REPLY

Jdth,

Please cut yourself some slack. I don't recommend looking at a youtube of a TKR, but I have and it's brutal. It's no wonder we hurt so much, lack energy and get down.

Thanks for listing what you feel like eating. I'll have some mashed potatoes and a fresh sandwich on hand. But I do plan to mainly use Stauffer's entres like salisbury steak with mashed potatoes and meatloaf with mac/cheese--after I get off my chicken noodle soup regimin. Oh, and toast with a bit of butter was tolerable. A toasted bagel might've been good too.

I'm pre-diabetic and have to watch carbs though. But I think during my lst 3 wks of recovery, I'll eat what appeals. I've chosen Jimmy Dean bacon/cheese,egg/muffin sandwiches for breakfast. I need things I can nuke. My husband will be at week and my daughter will only be here about a week. We have an old microwave in the basement which we'll put on the counter. I'm short and trying to reach the built in which is above my head, won't be easy or safe. I'll be constantly thinking about safety since I'll be on opioids and already have balance issues. I keep telling myself, slow and steady wins the race.

Do saltines appeal to you? Pudding? Ice cream? sorbet? graham crackers? Like I said before, the only thing I could eat right away was chicken noodle soup, and not much even. Just wasn't hungry.

Keep trying to support yourself,

Guitar lady

REPLY

Three years / had two surgeries and PT , nerve block. I feel worse and more pain and less range of motion than before. Now it is effecting my back and hip. I have sharp pain in the knee. It feels like implant is not the right size. Dr don’t care after they do surgery. Just bad luck.

REPLY
@healthtalk

Three years / had two surgeries and PT , nerve block. I feel worse and more pain and less range of motion than before. Now it is effecting my back and hip. I have sharp pain in the knee. It feels like implant is not the right size. Dr don’t care after they do surgery. Just bad luck.

Jump to this post

Hi @healthtalk
I share your frustration. I've posted this exact opinion. Following the surgery you are on your own. The surgeon does his/her thing with a procedure that they are taught, followed by PT with therapist practicing what they are taught and all differ to some degree, to the varied meds prescribed. I think that's why this forum is popular, i.e., somewhere where patients can express their feelings. In my case I've had three TKR surgeries over seven years, one being a revision, and endured all the recovery pain as described by other in this forum.
The day before my first surgery back in 2018 I finished up completing building a deck on my house by cleaning up and putting away ladders. Today the pain is worse and I walk with a bad limp. I wouldn't dare leave the house without my cane.

REPLY

It is so sad and frustrating
Sad story of American medical system. Went to best hospital of special surgery in NY. It is like assembly line. Don’t take medicare. Paid cash for surgery. Put nickel in my knee. Had allergic reaction knee is buckling and am falling down
Patient portal does not mention any of my symptoms. Lied and covered themselves. Only interested in making money. So sad

REPLY

I'm 7-1/2 months post TKR. I've seen my surgeon twice post surgery and have a 12-month post visit scheduled. I was feeling sorry I did this initially, but I am now walking pretty normally without a cane and working on doing better on stairs. I don't have stairs, so I don't get much practice. Just in the past 3 weeks the tingly feeling I had in my knee has decreased to just the lower knee. I have mild lymphedema in that leg, so the swelling was an issue even before surgery, but it's almost back to pre-surgery level. I've finally reached the point where I am glad I did it. Still, I hope I never need to do the other knee. It just isn't fun. I am still supplementing meals with one protein shake most days. I am pre-diabetic and have healed nicely.

REPLY
@sprinrosa64

More truth, no doctor mention 20percent of TKR have mid to major problems after. No doctor mentions the risks, other than possible infection or some stiffness. No doctor mentions this is a tough possible live changing surgery and not always for the better. Lets be honest if you are a lucky one it works, unlucky and you curse the day you did it

Jump to this post

Well said.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.