From all the stories on this forum I would not consider traveling more than I have to. I wouldn't let my confidence and likeability in a doctor be a deciding factor since it has absolutely no bearing on the outcome of your surgery. As stated in past stories it's a crapshoot. Some of the best surgeons have no bedside manners and vice versa. Also consider the pain in the first few weeks and the added discomfort of travel. All factors considered I would chose a closer doctor.