Anyone take Bone-Up calcium supplement?

Posted by debbik @debbik, Dec 2 1:30pm

I’m on a mission to change, adjust, add, anything to help my bone density improve. I’ve been taking Bone-Up for 5 years- since I’ve been diagnosed with osteoporosis, but my density continues to get worse. This supplement has Vitamin C, D, K2, magnesium but the calcium is elemental and says microcrystalline hydroxyapatite. Wondering if anyone out there takes this, or knows anything about it? Maybe I should switch to normal calcium supplement like Caltrate, or something else????

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

I was told 1200mg of calcium and 2000units of vit D.
After looking up "bone up", you may not be taking enough of either.

REPLY

Does including osteoporosis meds factor into your plan or you trying to improve without meds. Can you share your dexa scores.

REPLY
@gravity3

Does including osteoporosis meds factor into your plan or you trying to improve without meds. Can you share your dexa scores.

Jump to this post

Hi!! I’ve had reclast three times… the first two didn’t help at all as my bone density got worse each time. I’ve no idea why my dr had me do a third round. I recently found this site and am learning to be my own advocate and not rely totally on drs. I’m not sure about my score but I think my spine was -2.9. I fractured a bone in my spine a few years ago. I was asking about the bone up because although it says calcium, it’s not in the form that is mostly mentioned like calcium carbonate or calcium citrate. Also I’m wondering if algaeCal is better. Do you know anything about different types of calcium and their absorption?

REPLY

You should be able to access your dexa scores on your patient portal.
Someone with more calcium info should answer that question. Great that you are becoming your own best health advocate! There is a wealth of knowledge and experience here.
Make sure you are asking you doc why: why are you prescribing this drug, what is the science behind this drug for my osteoporosis and what is your treatment plan and thoughts about drug sequencing.
Is this your PCP or endocrinologist. What is this person's expertise in bone health. Don't be afraid to ask for a referral. Or self refer if that is an option in your medical system. Do your own research on best docs for osteoporosis.

REPLY
@debbik

Hi!! I’ve had reclast three times… the first two didn’t help at all as my bone density got worse each time. I’ve no idea why my dr had me do a third round. I recently found this site and am learning to be my own advocate and not rely totally on drs. I’m not sure about my score but I think my spine was -2.9. I fractured a bone in my spine a few years ago. I was asking about the bone up because although it says calcium, it’s not in the form that is mostly mentioned like calcium carbonate or calcium citrate. Also I’m wondering if algaeCal is better. Do you know anything about different types of calcium and their absorption?

Jump to this post

Looks like Bone Up contains calcium in the form of microcrystalline hydroxyapatite. I found this study that states it is similar in effectiveness to calcium citrate and calcium carbonate in suppressing bone turnover markers.

The main difference seems to be that it doesn't raise serum calcium levels (blood levels) quite as much as the other two forms of calcium.

"These findings suggest that Ca preparations, in general, produce repeated sustained increases in serum Ca concentrations after ingestion of each dose and that Ca supplements with smaller effects on serum Ca concentrations may have equivalent efficacy in suppressing bone turnover."

Link to study report: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25274192/

REPLY
@debbik

Hi!! I’ve had reclast three times… the first two didn’t help at all as my bone density got worse each time. I’ve no idea why my dr had me do a third round. I recently found this site and am learning to be my own advocate and not rely totally on drs. I’m not sure about my score but I think my spine was -2.9. I fractured a bone in my spine a few years ago. I was asking about the bone up because although it says calcium, it’s not in the form that is mostly mentioned like calcium carbonate or calcium citrate. Also I’m wondering if algaeCal is better. Do you know anything about different types of calcium and their absorption?

Jump to this post

Hi, calcium hydroxyapatite is already converted to the form if ca. that your body turns ca. into to make bone. It is harder to absorb however. Taking it with lemon juice or vinegar in water makes it more readily available. The beneficial thing about Jarrow Bone Up is that it has ingredients that go into making bone. Calcium is only one of those components.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.