← Return to How can HEPA charcoal filter benefit allergies and asthma?

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
@jeff1047

I would not recommend the level of HEPA/charcoal filtration that I have described to anyone who is not incredibly sensitive to mold and/or allergens. It's also important from those reading my posts to realize that filtration is only one facet of my environmental control measures.

If someone wants to start practicing environmental control I would recommend reading through text and watching the videos at (https://www.aaaai.org/tools-for-the-public/conditions-library/allergies/indoor-allergens-ttr). The only thing that you should ignore is the statement in the second video that "for the most part molds don't cause human disease." This is clearly not the case and is contradicted by several articles in JACI and JACI In Practice (the journals published by AAAAI).

If they want to see if room-sized particulate filters work for them they might want to start out with a Corsi-Rosenthal Box. It doesn't have any charcoal in it but it is much cheaper than the Foust and AllerAir units that @jenniferhunter and I have been talking about.

There is detailed info on the box (including instructions on how to build one) at the Corsi-Rosenthal Foundation website (https://corsirosenthalfoundation.org/ ) and a video interview with Jim Rosenthal at (https://www.iaqradio.com/jim-rosenthal-chief-executive-officer-tex-air-filters-air-cleaning-filtration-and-the-corsi-rosenthal-box/)

Jump to this post


Replies to "I would not recommend the level of HEPA/charcoal filtration that I have described to anyone who..."

@jeff1047 Jeff, this is great information. I like the Corsi-Rosenthal box. It's such a simple idea. We do use the furnace filters with the highest level of particulate filtration available. I also used to work in a research lab doing histology work, and the professor was very fussy about a dust free work space because if dust got into a microscope slide, an image of that tissue could not be published. This was long before digital photography in the days of film and darkrooms. He was wrapping the air registers with filmy fabric to catch dust.

During the beginning of Covid, when people were sewing masks because none could be purchased and limited supplies were needed by hospitals, I was looking up how well fabrics would filter smaller particles like an N95 mask or respirator. I read that denim fabric does pretty well, and I tried making a mask from it. I do keep a respirator with me when driving for those times when my lungs reactive to outside air. I also have run my Foust air filter in the car, but it is big and bulky and can fall over with starts and stops. They do also make a small model for vehicles.