← Return to Truth about Total Knee Replacements

Discussion

Truth about Total Knee Replacements

Joint Replacements | Last Active: 5 minutes ago | Replies (147)

Comment receiving replies
@catheem

I'm sorry to hear that! We all have individual reactions to our pain and to our improvements with one or the other modalities. I just like this 'forum' because I learn and sometimes benefit from one person, and sometimes not...AND my friends who've had TKR gave me a heck of a time about cancelling my TKR, and I finally said, 'I don't have pain anymore! Would you do it if your pain stopped?' That pretty much stopped them from making me feel guilty! BUT I am perfectly aware that anything can change in a heartbeat...at 70 years old, that statement is true for everything! Good luck to you!

Jump to this post


Replies to "I'm sorry to hear that! We all have individual reactions to our pain and to our..."

Unless you REALLY need it, do not have the procedure. I was competitively sprinting in the Sr. Games 2 years ago. Got 3 Meniscus tears. Repair left me hurting but with Cortisone, I could manage as long as my activity was low impact. It then seemed inevitable that I needed a new knee. Since then I had the TKR, MUA, Arthroscopic Debridement and an Open Debridement, due to excessive scar tissue. Now, I am very limited in my ROM, have endured almost 2 years of pain, rehab and lacking mobility. I would never have had the TKR if I had known. It is NO silver bullet for at least 2-10% of all who have the procedure. My next step is to go to the Mayo Clinic for revision to a hinged replacement. This allows them to remove all tendons, which is where a significant amount of the scarring is. The interacts the place of the tendons. KEEP YOUR ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT, if at all possible because a TKR is a crapshoot.

I'm 80 and just canceled my tkr surgery after reading these posts. What knee pain i do have doesn't compare to some of these results. I won't take the chance until there's no doubt.