← Return to Wondering if I'm taking the right path...

Discussion

Wondering if I'm taking the right path...

Breast Cancer | Last Active: Aug 23 8:48am | Replies (33)

Comment receiving replies
@kathyomaha55

I was so frustrated that my new oncologist (old one retired) at 5 years refused to do the Breast Cancer Index test to see if I would benefit from extended treatment. She said only if I agreed to take it for another 5 years would they order the test. I didn't agree to take it longer. I never understood that.

Jump to this post


Replies to "I was so frustrated that my new oncologist (old one retired) at 5 years refused to..."

@kathyomaha55 the BCI is in the NCCN guidelines. In other words it is now sanctioned best practice. The doctor requiring 10 years is making the BCI useless. (Also I read that 7 years was as good as 10, but that was a long time ago).

I printed out all the paperwork and filled it out so that the MD just had to sign. Do you think that would work?

I would be frustrated with that answer too. I just had the BCI test and I have been on Anastrozole for a little more than 4 years. I was stage 1a. Well the BCI test said I would benefit from an additional 5 years of taking the AI, however, I have already had two other oncologists tell me that don't even order the BCI for stage 1 because they said BCI does not differentiate between Stage 1 and 2 and his view is there is a difference that should be considered. Another oncologist said the risk for continuing in his view is not worth it given my current rate of recurrence would change to .8 of I extended for another 5 years and like 1.3 if I don't. So I have just learned over the last four years that some of the decisions made are based on what the Drs patient experience overall has been and the Drs best advice.