← Return to Support For Those Quitting Prolia

Discussion

Support For Those Quitting Prolia

Osteoporosis & Bone Health | Last Active: 5 days ago | Replies (85)

Comment receiving replies
@formisc

Thank you, rjd, for your thoughts and feedback, and i do think your "painting" analogy is appropriate!

I have read about the risks of doing any invasive dental work while on bisphosphonates so will be keeping this in mind on my dental visits

I believe the reference CTX range of 171-970 is not actually a target or ideal range but merely the observed CTX values of healthy people in the relevant age group. On the other hand, Dr McCormick was suggesting a target range of 100-375

For now, i plan to carry on with my weekly Alendronate and schedule another BTM test in 3-4 months

Many thanks and all the best!

Jump to this post


Replies to "Thank you, rjd, for your thoughts and feedback, and i do think your "painting" analogy is..."

You are quite correct about the typical CTX reference range. I had forgotten it simply reflects what was observed among healthy folks in various age groups.

Not very helpful therefore in trying to understand what might or might not be happening with a very low CTX score and whether/why it should be concerning.

Now that I have a bit better grasp of the concept of bone remodeling, I would be concerned about a low CTX score for the reasons given by McCormick.

Bone density and bone strength might be related but are likely not the same. While osteopenic, I took 2 very bad falls, each on a hard surface. One should have resulted in a broken wrist; the other in a broken bone in the hip area. They were both painful and took forever to get better....but no bone breaks.

Those 2 incidents began my personal questioning about bone density as the test for determining treatment. And about bone density increasing with bisphosphonate treatment, when the mechanism of that increase may be more like slapping on a coat of paint without proper prep work.

Surely this area of medical research and practice can do better. Best of luck with your bones.