Best Calcium Supplement?

Posted by SRKONA @trixie5141, Apr 22 7:20am

Which is the best type of calcium supplement? I've been taking calcium citrate (Citracal) which I understand is more easily absorbed than calcium carbonate (Caltrate). Most recently I've been hearing about calcium phosphate as an alternative. I like that it is available as a powder and may be less constipating than calcium citrate but it seems that is calcium phosphate is more for pets. Your thoughts?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

I hadn't thought of it that way. Thanks.

REPLY
@joyboudreau

Vitality Calcium Complete manufactured by Melaleuca.
https://www.melaleuca.com/productstore/supplements/calcium-complete
The research doesn’t show on the non member page above ☹️ Melaleuca is an inexpensive online membership based shop club. Not putting products on a shelf saves billions. And this method prevents the need for storage - all products are manufactured monthly.

Jump to this post

I looked up Vitality Calcium Complete and in order to purchase you have to become a member. Is there a cost to this? And you have to have someone refer you. What is the process?

REPLY
@bluebonnet242

@trixie5141 @guinivere I’m interested in which foods you are eating to get so much calcium. Would you please share?

Jump to this post

Trixie, I started on this but one of cats interrupted & so I will start again!
First of all, I take a daily Ensure Max Protein which is 650 mg of calcium. Also daily I usually take a glass of Minute Maid orange juice which is 350 per cup. I drink milk which is 300 mg per cup &/or Almond milk w. which is about 350 per cup. Also kefir - am looking at the label of my blueberry kefir now & it's 390 per cup.

Per day, I almost always have a glass of orange juice in the am, not a cup, & a glass of milk of some kind around noon. So with the Ensure...... there it's pretty easy I haven't gptten into sardines yet but I do like canned salmon with bones as a salad topping or in as sandwich. Re the milk, I will fairly frequently have more than one glass per day, be it regular milk or almond milk

REPLY
@bluebonnet242

@trixie5141 @guinivere I’m interested in which foods you are eating to get so much calcium. Would you please share?

Jump to this post

Two of my "go to" sources for calcium are Fairlife fat-free ultra-filtered lactose-free milk and GreatValue (Walmart) Almondmilk; I'm a fan of the chocolate.

REPLY

So many teach that we loose the enzymes needed to get the calcium from milk.

REPLY
@joyboudreau

So many teach that we loose the enzymes needed to get the calcium from milk.

Jump to this post

I tried Googling that and found nothing to support that theory. Milk is supplemented with vitamin d which increases absorption.
https://www.mayoclinichealthsystem.org/hometown-health/speaking-of-health/calcium-intake-and-absorption

REPLY

I appears you've got the basics nailed down. As always getting your nutritional needs met is always through foods rather than supplements. Vitamin D is necessary for calcium absorption, so you'll need to keep that in mind. I recently found an article (I posted link on another thread here) which warned about getting too much calcium from supplements as anything over 2000 mg per day can lead to hypercalcimia which causes heart disease. However, getting calcium naturally in foods has the opposite effect. Over 2000 mg from foods can actually reduce the plaque already in your heart's arteries. Here is an article on how to get the calcium you need naturally.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/in-depth/calcium-supplements/art-20047097

REPLY
@dlmdinia

I appears you've got the basics nailed down. As always getting your nutritional needs met is always through foods rather than supplements. Vitamin D is necessary for calcium absorption, so you'll need to keep that in mind. I recently found an article (I posted link on another thread here) which warned about getting too much calcium from supplements as anything over 2000 mg per day can lead to hypercalcimia which causes heart disease. However, getting calcium naturally in foods has the opposite effect. Over 2000 mg from foods can actually reduce the plaque already in your heart's arteries. Here is an article on how to get the calcium you need naturally.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/in-depth/calcium-supplements/art-20047097

Jump to this post

Hi everyone. I recently heard an interview about calcium with Margaret Martin and a supplement researcher and founder of Consumer Lab.
He said something that I had wondered about and suspected to be true. Calcium fortified foods act like supplements in our bodies, and shouldn't be considered the same as natural food sources for calcium. It was a fairly interesting interview.
He speaks about this at around 11:45. https://youtu.be/ehxKfZUDvXQ?si=7oSIalB5ymiTKfVK

REPLY
@dlmdinia

I appears you've got the basics nailed down. As always getting your nutritional needs met is always through foods rather than supplements. Vitamin D is necessary for calcium absorption, so you'll need to keep that in mind. I recently found an article (I posted link on another thread here) which warned about getting too much calcium from supplements as anything over 2000 mg per day can lead to hypercalcimia which causes heart disease. However, getting calcium naturally in foods has the opposite effect. Over 2000 mg from foods can actually reduce the plaque already in your heart's arteries. Here is an article on how to get the calcium you need naturally.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/in-depth/calcium-supplements/art-20047097

Jump to this post

I did not see this in the article you referenced but stated in your comment "Over 2000 mg from foods can actually reduce the plaque already in your heart's arteries." Where did you get that information from?

REPLY
@ninski

I looked up Vitality Calcium Complete and in order to purchase you have to become a member. Is there a cost to this? And you have to have someone refer you. What is the process?

Jump to this post

Sorry - I just saw this.
Shop Club membership is $19 a year…often $1 for first year with a promotion - like this week/next.

Any customer can refer a new member.

There is a six minute video with an enrollment link at the end covering shopping details.

The Preferred Customer monthly shopper gets a 30-50% discount and option for shipping paid for.

Regular customer, no perks - but no need to shop regularly.

That preferred program is what allows manufacturing predictability, fresh products, no warehousing.

Cancellation of Preferred Membership is easy and can be requested any time.

I have been a customer for 32 years - and have acquired huge trust overtime in all areas.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.