← Return to Signatera results: Does the increase mean cancer is back?

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
Profile picture for cjay @cjay

My 4th Signatera test results just came back, and for the first time since my resection surgery it’s a positive result of 1.02
I have my first CT scan (since my treatment ended) next week.
Trying to stay calm and positive until the scan results come back, but of course that’s difficult.
Does anyone have any experience similar? And what happened after that positive test?
🤞🙏

Jump to this post


Replies to "My 4th Signatera test results just came back, and for the first time since my resection..."

I'm sorry, I can't remember if you had chemo or not and when it ended.

In my case, even though the surgeons said they "got it all", I still had chemotherapy. I still had a "hot spot" in the area of the surgery which showed up on scans and in my CEA test about 6 months after I stopped chemo. Demoralizing, to say the least! It took about a year later for it to be knocked out by the chemo - apparently there are residual benefits to chemo as well as the debits. My next scan is late this month.

At one time, I had found a guide to understanding Signatera test results, but now can't find it. If I remember correctly (and I may not) that's a very low number.

There is reason to be concerned, but probably not to be fearful. Lag effect of the chemo leaving residual stuff still around can result in a positive result, and lab tests all have some margin for error/false positives and false negatives.

All the best.

If the oncologist thinks more chemo is necessary, then another port install would be indicated.

The oncologist may want to wait until the next scheduled scan and next Signatera test - that's what they did with mine when my CEA test bumped up.

All the best.

Thanks! And all the best to you also😘

Yes I have lots of Signatera info. After my resection my signatera test went from zeros to .03, .06, 1.1, 4.2. My cancer spots did not show up until this time with a 1/4 inch spot on my lung and a 1/2 spot on my liver. I did cryoablation to remove the spots. This procedure is a lot less invasive than radiation or surgery. My signatera went to 15 and we found a couple more spots that were also cryoablated. After this they put me back on chemo and my signatera is back to zero. After 8 treatments, they want me to continue 8 more to hopefully knock out any residual cancer cells that may have been left behind. The unknown is just scary with cancer. Knowing that cancer is coming back with the signatera tests is quite stressful. However, the signatera tests have been very helpful finding cancer spots very early to eliminate and keep from spreading elsewhere. Feel free to message me if you would like more detail or have more questions. It sounds like our cancers are similar but I have a year or so more experience dealing with this stuff. Stay positive! Reid

Thanks Reid! Stressful and disappointing along with a side helping of fear.
How long after your last treatment before the Signatera results started to register in the positive? I was hoping for an easy, breezy cancer-free block of time. Way more than the 4-6 months I got. The thought of having that port put back in scares the 🤬 out of me.
I’ve never heard of cryoablation, so thank you for that. I’m meeting with my oncology team Monday after they get the results of my 6 month scan Friday.
Did you go back in FOLFOX? Were you able to continue working? (I’ve only been back to work since December 1, after 11 months on medical leave.)
Insert anguished cry here.
Carol

Thanks Colleen, it’s been a week that I’ve been living with it, and I’m not as emotional wrecked as I originally was. I had my scan on Friday - showed no masses or signs of metastatic disease, but I know from what Reid told me things might be too minuscule to show up until the next scan. I have an appointment with my oncology team tomorrow after work, and a phone meeting Wednesday with my surgeon at MUSC. I should know more after those.
I did have a phone conference with a genetic counselor at Signatera, and she was helpful with understanding the numbers a bit more and some good general knowledge. Right now I’m hoping the circulating tumor dna is residual, rather than a new occurrence. And hoping for some new drug besides the FOLFOX if I do need chemo.
🙏🤞
I will update after I get some news.

I also had my 4th natera for breast cancer come back from 0 to 1.51
Scared couldn't believe it I cant do chemo or other chemical treatments because of another condition.

Realistically, any positive result is indicative of cancer recurrence or progression, surpassing traditional methods, and informing treatment decisions through the analysis of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). Although ctDNA is generally used to detect residual or remaining cancer following surgery or treatment, It is also capable of detecting new arising cancer. Any positive result should prompt you to seek more intense surveillance and possibly treatment because CTDNA tests can detect cancers 6 to 8 months before it can be seen on a CT or MRI. Although not widely advertised, The CTDNA test from Natera used for breast cancer detects new cancers in only 50% of cases. So if you have a positive result You should consider that it reflects new or residual cancer even after 2 years. Ask your doctor about newly available tests from Natera competitor Exact Sciences, since technology is very rapidly increasing and testing is continuing to improve almost month by month.

I believe this was mentioned in similar posts recently, but remember that Signatera is able to detect cancer 6 to 8 months before it is capable of being seen on a CT or MRI. So you could have a positive result and a negative scan.... But at least you're oncologist will focus on surveillance and be looking intently for a tumor. And then treatment can begin at a stage when the tumor is much more treatable than an advanced stage. So try to look at a initial positive ctDNA result as a plus In the overall perspective.