Hi Amber, I'm sorry that this is a late response to your original post. I have hashimoto's thyroiditis it's an autoimmune disease. I want to encourage you to see your regular doctors along with a natural path or integrated medicine doctor. Integrated medicine doctors test your vitamins and minerals things normal doctors don't. Tingling sensations can often be low b vitamins. I have a lot of joint pain and do not have arthritis. Fish oil, hyaluronic acid, supplements helped tremendously. I take a multitude of supplements. Magnesium helps with pain. I also do vitamin IVs and that helps tremendously. Do research on your vitamins and minerals include that in your care. It's a journey and they all work together I also see a chiropractor monthly and that helps as well.