Physical limitations with Leaky Valve

Posted by ficklefinn @ficklefinn, Aug 27, 2025

My two cardiologists have differing views:
One wants me to keep below 1,000 feet elevation and not to lift more than 30 pounds.
The second has no limitations on altitude and thinks 30 pounds is far too low but did not give me a limit! His only guidance is to monitor blood pressure and breathing as he says there is no studies on this.
Thank you for your input.
Mike

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Heart & Blood Health Support Group.

PS- I can’t tolerate nitroglycerin because I get migraines.

REPLY

Whoops, sorry, I think that nitroglycerin comment ended up in the wrong place.

REPLY

I’m a 75 year old guy who just had a stress echo that revealed a +4 mitral valve prolapse. The ventricals are normal in size and the ejection factor is 64%. I’m supposed to meet with a cardiologist soon but I was wondering if anyone has any experience with mitral valve repair surgery, conventional or robotic, or if they decided the MitaClip instead. Comments and suggestions welcome.
Lou

REPLY
Profile picture for susanejw @susanejw

@jlharsh Hi Janell, I’m a 73 year old woman, fit and thin. My issues have gradually increased over the past seven years or so. First labile high blood pressure, tachycardia, and partially clogged arteries, for which I used beta blockers and then statins. I noticed my diastolic blood pressure was usually low, even when the systolic was high, so a heart cat scan revealed the leaky valves. Then a stress test indicated a blockage, so I had a cardiac catheterization a few weeks ago, which showed my arteries are only 30% blocked, so they said I must have coronary microvascular disease. I’m very interested in talking with to others with CMD, and I have some specific questions. I live in a rural area, and I don’t know whether my cardiologists are up to snuff.
Is CMD caused by plaque, or by malfunctioning blood vessels?
And, does having CMD increase my chances of having a heart attack or stroke?
I try to walk slowly about 2 miles a day, but lately I’m often doing less, and I don’t know if I should push myself beyond my comfort zone. Hills are always a challenge, usually causing shortness of breath and faintness.
Is small vascular disease systemic? Could it be causing memory problems?
Thanks for noticing my comment. 🙂

Jump to this post

I can learn a lot from you, @susanejw. Thank you for your comment.

I am going to look a bit at discussions and see what I can find. In the meantime, if you haven’t already you can go to the box at the top of Connect home page and type words you want to search for. Also, here are resources I found:
- Mayo Clinic CMD treatment: https://www.mayoclinic.org/medical-professionals/cardiovascular-diseases/news/expanding-the-possibilities-of-treatment-options-for-patients-with-coronary-microvascular-disease/mac-20581614
- Small Vessel Disease Summary: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/small-vessel-disease/diagnosis-treatment/drc-20352123
- American Heart Association CMD Overview: https://www.heart.org/en/health-topics/heart-attack/angina-chest-pain/coronary-microvascular-disease-mvd

I have never heard of labile high blood pressure. This is the 2nd time in a couple of days. Would you check out this discussion https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/labile-hypertension-how-to-improve-it/

I am interested to learn what you find out. I love you questions and will learn, myself. Will you come back and comment? Hopefully, @ficklefinn will have an update about pushing activity levels as well.

REPLY
Profile picture for neronel @neronel

I’m a 75 year old guy who just had a stress echo that revealed a +4 mitral valve prolapse. The ventricals are normal in size and the ejection factor is 64%. I’m supposed to meet with a cardiologist soon but I was wondering if anyone has any experience with mitral valve repair surgery, conventional or robotic, or if they decided the MitaClip instead. Comments and suggestions welcome.
Lou

Jump to this post

@neronel
I had mitral valve repair (minimally invasive, where the surgeon goes between the ribs rather than a sternotomy) about a year and a half ago when I was 69. The surgeon tried to also place a clip, but wasn't able to do so. The mitral valve repair was successful and I haven't had any problems and up to full physical activity - hiked 10 miles yesterday with 2,000' of elevation gain.
All the best!

REPLY
Profile picture for aard @aard

@neronel
I had mitral valve repair (minimally invasive, where the surgeon goes between the ribs rather than a sternotomy) about a year and a half ago when I was 69. The surgeon tried to also place a clip, but wasn't able to do so. The mitral valve repair was successful and I haven't had any problems and up to full physical activity - hiked 10 miles yesterday with 2,000' of elevation gain.
All the best!

Jump to this post

@aard
Thank you for the information. Can you tell the degree of your prolapse, like +3 or +4? Also, were you diagnosed after a stress echo (treadmill)? What made you decide on the minimally invasive surgery?
Thanks,
Lou

REPLY

I don't remember precisely, but I think it was in the +3 range. Diagnosis was not after a stress echo, but I had been getting echo-cardiograms on a yearly basis because of the prolapse to see if things were getting worse; they had been monitoring this for a few years after my EP heard a heart murmur (i.e., the leaky valve). The main reason to go with the mitral valve repair was because my afib, which had been controlled after my ablation, was popping up again. Mitral valve prolapse can cause afib.
Minimally invasive surgery was the decision of my cardio-thoracic surgeon. If it wasn't something he thought could be done with minimally invasive surgery, the alternative would have been a thoracotomy. Minimally invasive is apparently a bit more painful, but heals more quickly.
The only potential drawback was maybe not being able to place the mitral clip; he may have been able to do that if he did a thoracotomy, but that's speculation on my part.
If you do have the surgery, I would highly recommend getting into a cardiac rehab program afterwards; it will really help to figure out what you can and cannot do and get you back on your feet.

REPLY
Profile picture for aard @aard

I don't remember precisely, but I think it was in the +3 range. Diagnosis was not after a stress echo, but I had been getting echo-cardiograms on a yearly basis because of the prolapse to see if things were getting worse; they had been monitoring this for a few years after my EP heard a heart murmur (i.e., the leaky valve). The main reason to go with the mitral valve repair was because my afib, which had been controlled after my ablation, was popping up again. Mitral valve prolapse can cause afib.
Minimally invasive surgery was the decision of my cardio-thoracic surgeon. If it wasn't something he thought could be done with minimally invasive surgery, the alternative would have been a thoracotomy. Minimally invasive is apparently a bit more painful, but heals more quickly.
The only potential drawback was maybe not being able to place the mitral clip; he may have been able to do that if he did a thoracotomy, but that's speculation on my part.
If you do have the surgery, I would highly recommend getting into a cardiac rehab program afterwards; it will really help to figure out what you can and cannot do and get you back on your feet.

Jump to this post

@aard ....oops, that should be "the alternative would have been a sternotomy," not thoracotomy.

REPLY
Profile picture for neronel @neronel

I’m a 75 year old guy who just had a stress echo that revealed a +4 mitral valve prolapse. The ventricals are normal in size and the ejection factor is 64%. I’m supposed to meet with a cardiologist soon but I was wondering if anyone has any experience with mitral valve repair surgery, conventional or robotic, or if they decided the MitaClip instead. Comments and suggestions welcome.
Lou

Jump to this post

@neronel, I had a mitral valve prolapse with severe regurgitation. I had no symptoms, other than a heart murmur, when I was examined for carpal tunnel syndrome.
One cardiologist told me to call him when I started getting short of breath, but a different cardiologist told me there were better outcomes when people had surgery before they went into Congestive Heart Failure. I took his advice and had open heart surgery, a repair, with a ring. I think I also had a Mitraclip. I was 69 at the time. I was in the hospital for two weeks after surgery with some complications, but I'm glad I had it done when I did.

REPLY
Profile picture for Janell, Volunteer Mentor @jlharsh

I can learn a lot from you, @susanejw. Thank you for your comment.

I am going to look a bit at discussions and see what I can find. In the meantime, if you haven’t already you can go to the box at the top of Connect home page and type words you want to search for. Also, here are resources I found:
- Mayo Clinic CMD treatment: https://www.mayoclinic.org/medical-professionals/cardiovascular-diseases/news/expanding-the-possibilities-of-treatment-options-for-patients-with-coronary-microvascular-disease/mac-20581614
- Small Vessel Disease Summary: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/small-vessel-disease/diagnosis-treatment/drc-20352123
- American Heart Association CMD Overview: https://www.heart.org/en/health-topics/heart-attack/angina-chest-pain/coronary-microvascular-disease-mvd

I have never heard of labile high blood pressure. This is the 2nd time in a couple of days. Would you check out this discussion https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/labile-hypertension-how-to-improve-it/

I am interested to learn what you find out. I love you questions and will learn, myself. Will you come back and comment? Hopefully, @ficklefinn will have an update about pushing activity levels as well.

Jump to this post

@jlharsh Thank you for the links! I had already read some, but the hour-glass-shaped stent idea from the Mayo Clinic was new to me. Sounds promising, but I don’t really want to rush into another surgery, and I’ll have to see if the procedure is even done in this country yet. But it’s good to know about.
I don’t really see how it works, actually, because it’s still a constriction. But if it works to alleviate angina somehow, that’s great.
About @ficklefinn ’s questions, I should have also told you both that my cardiologist didn’t give me any advice about traveling in the Sierras. I just went by how I felt. At 6,000 feet I could walk a couple miles, same as normal, and at 10,000 I had to return to the car and ask that we descend before hiking. That was in 2023, before my coronary microvascular dysfunction had kicked in, which probably would have made it worse.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.