Jpouch vs Ileostomy
Hi,
My colectomy is in two weeks and I need to decide whether to go for a J pouch vs a permanent ileostomy. Looking to hear from anyone who has had either / both.
I am 42y old male, with UC for last 18y. I was taking Risankizumab jabs and my UC symptoms were broadly in control, despite colonoscopy showing some activity.
My last scope revealed cancer with sygnet cells and now the doctors advise removing the whole colon. My primary surgeon advise a J pouch given my age and absence of Chrons
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Ostomy & J-Pouch Support Group.
Connect

Hi @singaporeucc and welcome to Connect.
There are a lot of success stories and satisfaction with j-pouches, but unfortunately I am not one of them. The short story is that while I was diagnosed with UC when I had the j-pouch in 1987, it later turned out that I had Crohn's Disease. I had constant inflammation in the j-pouch, and eventually had it removed and a permanent ileostomy.
I've had a very active life with my permanent ileostomy; it really doesn't limit me at all. Given all the complications I had with the j-pouch, I do wish we had known I had Crohn's when I had my colectomy.
I know that really doesn't help much, the ileostomy is a simpler surgery with fewer complications, and the j-pouch offers a simpler lifestyle without an external appliance.
Which way are you leaning?
Thank you for your reply.
My primary surgeon is recommending J pouch and I am leaning towards giving it a try.
But again part of me wants to be safe as well
Dear friend, I had my j-pouch surgery 40 yrs ago and have lived a wonderful life since. It was a process and adjustment but worth it. Best of wishes to you.
@singaporeucc if it is an option to meet with a WOCN prior to the surgery to have your belly marked for ostomy placement, it may be helpful to talk with them and perhaps look and feel the appliances. Even if you're having a temporary ostomy, having the WOCN mark where the ostomy should go so that is well placed is important.
Are you seeing a wocn before the surgery?
Can someone help me - I have a similar question on whether to choose J-pouch or Ileostomy ... I am in a high-pressure senior role, often in meetings and presentation with external people, which would sustain my lifestyle- personal ( I like to travel, have young children) and professional ( as above) better? Where would I have more control of my bowels?
For example, with a J-pouch can I be continent enough to look for a toilet say 10 doors down in a hotel conference room or at a busy airport? Will I leak? With an Ileostomy bag would I leak?
Would be grateful for some real life experiences? Thank you
@nabs Welcome to Connect!
I have real life experiences with both a j-pouch and an ileostomy. I'm not sure if my experiences are going to help you narrow it down, though, because I was able to travel, work in a high pressure job, as well as backpack and swim and scuba dive, with both the j-pouch and the ileostomy.
Because I have Crohn's disease I wound up with chronic inflammation in the j-pouch, so it was easier and less stressful when I had a permanent ileostomy. The Crohn's disease resulted in anal abscess and fistulas, Had I had the Crohn's diagnosis when I had the j-pouch constructed, I would not have had a j-pouch.
What is the reason you're looking at having a total colectomy, with either an ileostomy or a j-pouch?
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 Reactions@susanf8
Thank you @susanf8 .
It is a small rectal lesion - cancer is in its first stages but a very aggressive form and with a history of severe UC, a total is needed. Doctors in London have said so; I agree and am ok with that.
I am leaning towards J-pouch as both ileostomy & J-pouch seem to have a lists of pros and cons, which I am learning to cope with.
Just wanted to understand if I am leaving anything to chance if I go for the J-pouch ? Would you or anyone have experience of or know anyone who has kept the rectal cuff ( to staple the J pouch) hasn't regretted not going all belts and braces? I am asking this because of the type of cancer. Thank you
@nabs if there is mucosa left in the rectal cuff, then there is a possibility of continuing UC in the cuff. This is something you should discuss with your doctors.
I was diagnosed with UC back in the 1980s, and had a j-pouch in 1987. Diagnostic techniques have come a long way since then, and perhaps if I was diagnosed more recently they would have realized it was Crohn's disease instead of ulcerative colitis.
If you do, in fact, have Crohn's disease instead of UC, a j-pouch is a bad idea. I had multiple surgeries to deal with anal, abscesses and fissures, I had a j-pouch and vaginal fistula, and the surgery to remove the j-pouch was not trivial.
There are many j-pouch success stories. But it is a more complicated surgery, and usually (I think) is done with a temporary ostomy.
How confident are doctors that an ulcerative colitis diagnosis?
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 ReactionsI had my colon removed when I was 70 because of severe UC. I debated J-Pouch versus Ileostomy and my surgeon recommended the latter but said he would do a J-Pouch if I wanted it because I presented as a much younger person. I sought a 2nd opinion from a a renowned gastroenterologist and he recommended ileostomy too. So I went with the ileostomy and I am very glad I did. They also removed my anus because I had UC in it too and did not want to have cancer show up down the line. I never had cancer just severe UC. I had UC for 18 years which gradually got worse even with strong medicine in the latter years. I now have a bag (plastic colon) which is the best way to go for me. I am 78 now and work out 3 times a week at the gym, play golf, drive a semi for FedEx and am enjoying life. I think for me a J-Pouch would have been the wrong choice. Maybe for some, especially younger people, it would be an acceptable choice but the Ileostomy does not limit your life style any more than a J-Pouch. I had heard of problems with a J-Pouch and I did not want to expose myself to any of them. My personal opinion is that the small intestine was never designed to act as a colon.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
3 Reactions@fckaiser thank you!