No cause found for persistent pleural effusions

Posted by cindyconstien @cindyconstien, Dec 24, 2018

I have been treated for 2 years for pleural effusions. All fluid and blood work comes back clean - no cancer, infection, virus - nothing. They had been tapping both lungs and getting 1.5 to 2 liters from each side. The heart has been checked out (EKGs, Echos, stress tests) and there are no issues.
In April I had a bi lateral pleurodesis performed with biopsies from my left lung (no issues). They used talc and 7 months later I just had 1.8 liters drawn from the right lung. They believe the left side was moderately successful but the right side failed. I'm about to schedule a redo on the right, perhaps using the chemical option. I am also looking at possible "constrictive pericarditis" and will get another echo today, possibly leading to a heart cath to look closer.
I am a non smoker, relatively fit. I ran marathons and triathlons, ate appropriately, non diabetic. Only medication is for cholesterol management and inhalers to try to relieve my breathing discomfort.
I'd like to treat the cause - not the symptoms.

Any ideas?
Rob C.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Lung Health Support Group.

Yes - a Rheumatologist at Clev Clinic

REPLY

Hi ya’ll, so relieved I found this group. My last PET scan in early Nov 2020 showed I was cancer free now after stage IV NSCLC and other tumors. Since my lung cancer diagnosis, Jun 2019, I have had chronic fluid on my right lung. The fluid was tested with the first needle draw, 1,700cc, and found no infection. After 6 needle draws they inserted a catheter in the right lung. My wife is a retired RN so we drain the lung at home every 3rd day per the Dr recommendation. The fluid color has gotten darker, close to black coffee color, and the amount of fluid has remained consistent for the past 10 months at about 500cc. We’re going on a year dealing with this and still no relief in sight. Every Dr, oncologist, we have seen gives us the same “I don’t know what’s causing it” answer and mentions the talc treatment. I have an appointment with a thoracic Dr on 23 Feb, next Tue., and hoping they can provide some answers and recommend treatments. The questions raised in this group are identical to mine and from what I’m reading the talc treatment is not very successful. I really appreciate the honesty here and any suggestions would be greatly welcomed. I don’t feel so alone now, thank you..

REPLY

I have some questions and am hoping someone can shed some light on them.. When we drain my lung every 3 days we get about the same amount, 500cc. Just prior to reaching 500cc I experience sharp grabbing pains in the lung and have to cough. If I let the drain continue the pain increases but the fluid flow does not decrease. When they were taking the fluid off with a needle they stopped when I told them I felt the grabbing pains. So, we shut the catheter off now when the pain starts? Is the grabbing pain normal ? What causes the pain ? Am I supposed to continue draining until the lung is completely drained ? What are you doing if you have this problem? Would appreciate any input.. Dutch

REPLY

Sorry you're going through this. Our circumstances seem different, but yes I had some significant pain on occasion. They would take +/- 2 liters at a time from either lung, but a couple times I got a very sharp painful stab at the tap location. They decided not to draw down the fluid so much. Once my BP dropped so low they rushed me into the ER. They began to lower my head as soon as the tap was done to prevent the BP drop. The pleurodesis (talc) seems to have worked, breathing is better but not great. Last CT shows that the pockets of remaining fluid are holding steady or reducing. Good luck.

REPLY
@cindyconstien

Sorry you're going through this. Our circumstances seem different, but yes I had some significant pain on occasion. They would take +/- 2 liters at a time from either lung, but a couple times I got a very sharp painful stab at the tap location. They decided not to draw down the fluid so much. Once my BP dropped so low they rushed me into the ER. They began to lower my head as soon as the tap was done to prevent the BP drop. The pleurodesis (talc) seems to have worked, breathing is better but not great. Last CT shows that the pockets of remaining fluid are holding steady or reducing. Good luck.

Jump to this post

Thanks for responding and the info. Rob, it helps. I don’t think my BP drops, haven’t checked it, but that could account for why I feel exhausted after we draw. I’m thinking we are only getting about half the fluid off before the pain starts. My breathing is not good but doesn’t seem to improve or worsen after we draw. Looks like we will just have to live with this for the time being and will continue to stop the draw when the pain starts. I’m still undecided about pleurodesis. Hoping to see a thoracic surgeon when we return home next month to further discuss pleurodesis. What color is the fluid when you draw and has the color changed? Mine is dark bloody color and remained consistent, except for when I had radiation on the left lung, and then it turned several shades darker. It has since returned to the previous color. Man, this stuff has sure been a life changer. I even gave up my motorcycle and haven’t been in a bar fight for almost 2 years LOL..Thanks again, take care of yourself.. Dutch

REPLY
@nursed2075

Hi, your Dr can put a pleurex which can be drain daily depending on how much fluid is there. Home health can assist with this.

Jump to this post

Beware. These pleurex catheters get blocked , can become infected , and very often are taken out .. plus the constant reminder when sleeping or showering .. Also, I had such a horrible experience with surgery for the masectomy , that I m afraid to have more surgery that can be avoided , so I am stuck with thoracentesis for now , in hopes the fluid wil resolve on Ibrance and Faslodfex .

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.